The Telegraph calls it 'a landmark legal challenge'.
In the past, legal action against Palestinian terrorists was focused in the US, where those who aided those terrorists were put on trial, or the terrorist groups themselves were sued for damages.
Now, the focus has changed from the US to Europe--and the EU itself is being sued:
Mr Katorza has demanded EU "reparations for lost job income, reparations for
physical and psychological damages, reparations for property damages, monies for
reinforced buildings against missiles or any other military projectiles".
The dual French-Israeli citizen, from Sderot in Israel's Negev region, has lost his
job and family business because of Qassam rocket attacks launched from the Gaza
strip by Hamas.
His lawyers have cited clauses in the EU Treaties that offer protection to Europeans even while they are living abroad.
It is not merely an issue of the EU fulfilling their apparent obligation to protect the 300,000 Europeans living in Israel--according to Katorza, the EU is at the same time guilty of aiding Hamas because it has failed to
prevent the misuse of European funds by non-profit organisations which use
these funds to finance terrorism.
Katorza's lawyer adds
The EU grants hundreds of millions of euros a year in aid to Gaza, and it is
inconceivable that European citizens should be harmed by money supplied by the
EU. It's time that the EU takes responsibility.
The Jerusalem Post is providing an email contact for those Europeans in Israel who live withing range of the Hamas rockets and want to join in the lawsuit.
For its part, the US has not done much to protect its citizens either--nor to punish American citizens who are murdered by Palestinian terrorists. On October 15, 2003, 3 Americans were murdered. Jeff Jacoby reported at the time:
Three Americans -- John Branchizio, Mark Parson, and John Martin Linde -- were
murdered last Wednesday when terrorists in Gaza bombed the diplomatic convoy
they were riding in. News accounts immediately described the attack as a first
-- "an unprecedented deadly attack on a U.S. target in the Palestinian
territories," to quote the Associated Press. But Branchizio, Parson, and Linde
were not the first Americans to be murdered by Palestinian terrorists. They were
the 49th, 50th, and 51st in the past 10 years alone. A few hours after their
deaths, the White House condemned "the vicious act of terrorism" that killed
them, extended "heartfelt condolences to the families," and promised "to bring
the terrorists to justice."
At the time, the PA went through the motions of apprehending the killers:
Following the attack, PA Leader Yasser Arafat at first arrested three low-level
members of the splinter organization Popular Front and held a quick trial that
the U.S. called a sham, but he later caved into pressure and admitted the three
may not have been involved in the attack. The perpetrators remain at large.
One year later, in October 2004, the topic came up again when:
a senior Palestinian official publicly admitted for the first time he knows
the identity of the killers.Musa Arafat, the head of PA military intelligence and a cousin of Yasser
Arafat, said, "The Palestinian security forces know who was behind the killing
of three Americans in Gaza nearly a year ago, but cannot act against the
factions while the fighting with Israel continues."
The last effort made on behalf of the murdered Americans came last year with the sponsoring of HR 2293:
To require the Secretary of State to submit to Congress a report on efforts
to bring to justice the Palestinian terrorists who killed John Branchizio, Mark
Parson, and John Marin Linde.
You can see what progress was made on the bill at GovTrack.us:
The New York Sun noted on January 2, 2008 that the bill:
is now languishing in the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, where three
Democrats on the panel, Joseph Biden, Christopher Dodd, and Barack Obama, were
too busy running for president to forward the bill to the full Senate.
Israel Matzav, at the time, went into detail on the failure of the White House to pursue this matter.
The murder of these 3 Americans is among the topics that Obama did not find time to mention in his Cairo speech either. It remains to be seen whether the EU will follow through on its legal responsibilities and do more to protect its citizens in Israel than the US has.
UPDATE: Barry Rubin writes that the terrorist who murdered John Branchizio, Mark Parson, and John Marin Linde was himself killed by Israel last year.
By Daled Amos
Posted by daledamos at August 11, 2009 2:29 PMOdd, that this was posted today. Today would have been Johnny's birthday. Happy Birthday Johnny!! Semper Fidelis!
Posted by: Erin at August 11, 2009 5:41 PMI recently came across your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I don't know what to say except that I have enjoyed reading. Nice blog. I will keep visiting this blog very often.
Margaret
Posted by: Margaret at August 11, 2009 11:25 PMif the innocent israeli victims of palestinian terror can sue the EU on the basis of funding the palestinians of gaza[hamas], shouldn't the innocent palestinian civillians dispossed of their homes by israeli settlements be able to sue the USA which basically funds israels illegal expansion?
Posted by: sass at August 12, 2009 1:28 AM80 years on, the scars still show
Aug. 10, 2009
Tovah Lazaroff, THE JERUSALEM POST
On his freckled forehead, one can still see the scar from the knife wound Shlomo Slonim sustained 80 years ago, when an Arab stabbed him as he huddled in his mother's arms in their Hebron home.
"It's not the only wound I have," Slonim told The Jerusalem Post on Sunday. He opened up the palm of his hand to show scars on the insides of his fingers.
"There is one that I cannot bend," said the 81-year-old, who was dressed in black slacks and a light blue, short-sleeved, button-down shirt.
He wore glasses and a knitted kippa and spoke calmly as he stood in the Hebron cemetery, at the end of a small ceremony marking the Hebrew anniversary of the 1929 massacre of 67 Jewish residents of that city by an Arab mob.
Slonim recounted the details of that fateful day, when he was only a year old. He has no memory of the events, of course, but he has heard the story so many times that he told it as if he were recalling his own experiences.
It was Shabbat morning when an Arab mob armed with knives filled the streets and burst into Jewish homes, Slonim said.
Dozens of Jews, he said, had gathered in his parents' home for safety. His father, Eliezer Dan Slonim, 29, had been the director of the Anglo-Palestine Bank and a representative of the Jewish community in the Hebron Municipality.
Given the good relationship he enjoyed with his Arab neighbors, local Jews believed they would be safe in his home, said Slonim.
They were wrong. As the Arabs came to the home, the people inside tried to bar the door with their bodies, but they couldn't hold back the mob, he said.
After bursting in, the Arabs killed 24 people with knives and machetes. Among them were Slonim's father, his mother, Hannah, 24, and her parents who were visiting for Shabbat. They also fatally wounded his older brother, who was only four. He succumbed to his wounds several days later in Jerusalem and was buried there.
The lone survivor of his immediate family, Slonim comes as often as he can to the cemetery to visit his parents' graves, which are among the many graves of massacre victims marked by a long row of small headstones.
As is customary in Jewish tradition, he placed a small stone on each grave on Sunday.
The massacre destroyed the Hebron Jewish community, whose roots go back to biblical times, even though there were other periods when Jews were chased out of the city.
Some Jews tried to return to Hebron after the massacre, but the British removed them in 1936.
It was only in 1979 that Jews returned to live in Hebron. While those Jews who came saw themselves as the spiritual descendents of the former community, very few of the survivors or their descendents were among them.
Slonim said that he had thought about returning, but did not want to live among people who had killed his family.
"I would never know if the Arab I passed in the street had a hand in their murder," he said.
Slonim was not the only survivor to return Sunday to the cemetery for the ceremony organized by the Jewish community of Hebron. Yankele Hillel, 81, said that an Arab neighbor had saved him and his mother.
One woman, Menuha, said that her great-grandmother, for whom she was named, had survived because she hid behind a closet.
Among those who arrived at the cemetery was Rabbi Moshe Levinger, who in 1968 brought Jews back to Hebron to celebrate Pessah. They moved into rooms in a local hotel and refused to leave until a compromise was brokered, which led to the creation of the nearby settlement of Kiryat Arba.
Levinger came to the cemetery in a wheelchair on Sunday, hours after he had been released from the hospital. He was inspired, he said, by the spirit of the holy ones who were buried there.
A national ceremony in honor of the victims will be held next month.