He is becoming more bilious, if that's possible. This is actually from an interview in a Turkish newspaper. Here is one of his answers:
I think Israel, as a number of commentators pointed out, is becoming an insane state. And we have to be honest about that. While the rest of the world wants peace, Europe wants peace, the U.S. wants peace, but this state wants war, war and war. In the first week of the massacres, there were reports in the Israeli press that Israel did not want to put all its ground forces in Gaza because it was preparing attacks on Iran. Then there were reports it was planning attacks on Lebanon. It is a lunatic state.One question asked "How do you feel about Israel's operation in Gaza personally as the son of Holocaust survivors?" His answer:
It has been a long time since I felt any emotional connection with the state of Israel, which relentlessly and brutally and inhumanly keeps these vicious, murderous wars. It is a vandal state. There is a Russian writer who once described vandal states as Genghis Khan with a telegraph. Israel is Genghis Khan with a computer. I feel no emotion of affinity with that state. I have some good friends and their families there, and of course I would not want any of them to be hurt. That said, sometimes I feel that Israel has come out of the boils of the hell, a satanic state. Ninety percent of the population continues to cheer, to exalt and feel proud and heroic. They send a Sherman tank to a playground and torch children . . .Asked why the U.S. media is so "pro-Israel," he answers that Israel "serves American interests." Then he adds:
And there is, of course, the secondary factor, which is the ethnic element. In many of these newspapers and the media in general, there is a large Jewish presence, and there is a sense of Jewish ethnic solidarity, which plays a role.But there are also good Jews:
But I think we have to qualify the secondary factor in two ways. We should not lose sight of the primary factor, which is Israel is the client state of U.S. No. 2: In this past war, the liberal Jewish population mostly under the age of 40 completely defected from the war, the massacre. They have been opposed to the massacres from the first day.That's a relief. We wouldn't want those Muslim readers to come away from this with anti-Jewish feelings or anything.
Crossposted on Judeopundit
Posted by Judeopundit at February 15, 2009 10:30 PM"And we have to be honest about that. While the rest of the world wants peace, Europe wants peace, the U.S. wants peace"
....................................
The jihadists don't want peace. Iran, Syria, hamas and hezbollah and al qaeda do not want peace.
It's quite obvious that finkelstein is projecting his own insanity onto Israel and its supporters.
Posted by: Laura at February 15, 2009 11:37 PMLaura, I have to agree with you. I would like to know which country in this world would put up with rockets fired into its population daily?
This man is an apologist and I feel sorry for his children who have to live with him.
Posted by: Scott at February 16, 2009 6:03 AMMore antisemtic propaganda crap. Finklestein is a fradulant sell out of the human race.He's a failiure grasping for whatever attention he can get. He thinks that by turning his back on his heritage and history, he can use the attention to make a quick buck or two. His thought process is rulled by this along with the mighty dollar.
Always be weary when someone accuses another of satanic actions. Who knows which one actually has the forked togue to plant distrust, lies and deceit.
Posted by: Angryman at February 16, 2009 6:30 AMFinklestein is one of the few academics willing to tell the truth and he has paid a price for his honesty. Israel is out of control and we should end all aid to this corrupt gang or criminals.
Posted by: Art S. at February 16, 2009 7:12 AMFor many years I used to identify with the pain people went through during the 2nd world war in particular the Jewish and East European population. However, the past few years I have become increasingly frustrated by the way media uses the suffering caused by Fascism to excuse the Israeli behaviour in Lebanon and against Palestinians and treat any criticism which may be expressed against certain behaviour of some Jews as anti Semitic and hence subject to imprisonment. Europe must stop Israel and change their behaviour if America is unwilling to do so.
Posted by: Zoe Ford at February 16, 2009 7:25 AMWell Israel reacts to violence with violence, but can the blame be put on Israel alone? Nope, still Israel is stupid, like everyone else. Not thinking much how to end the conflict, everyone prefers to save their own skin and to hell with everybody else.
What must be understood that in face of adversity such as Israel faces, it's very hard to think clearly. You are being attacked brutally and mercilessly and in horror or in wish to save yourself you bash out to stop your suffering inflicted by others.
Israel feels threatened and abused and wants to preserve itself so no wonder that they mess up in feverish fight for survival..
Maybe Israel is arrogant... selfish... which I have heard younger Israelis saying about their country.
If no sides in this conflict will stop to take time to think about more intelligent solutions then we can expect to see more of primitive conflict.
Violence creates more violence and it's hard to get out of it's vicious circle once you are in it.
But to continue to devalue human life by allowing yourselves to support war must be stopped somehow or the hell won't ever end.
i fill sorry for you if you continue calling the people of GOD that are satan
even if it were you will you sit down and wait when someone continue provoking you to an extend of even killing your siblings?
Have you people lost your minds!!!????
AND what does this do with his children living with him,some people do indeed have crappy minds,
When had humankind justified when innocent children being killed in an awful ways and in hundreds,that happens when they are turned to monsters or satanic followers(yes I'm calling it satanic actions),
Not only justifying and also supporting the monster and biting at those who ever say stop.
ALL THAT for just some inferior stories of monster actions that we weren't even born to witness,
The man didn't turn his back on his heritage and history,he's just being honest with himself,and about rockets being fired ask the israeli officials they will tell you not one damn settler was killed may be few(I mean few)were injured,
People should open there eyes even for alittle while,truth is so clear it will memorized even if you only have a glance at it.
The word, "Satanic" is far over-used and mis-used and refers more to the self-righteousness in man. However, Finkelstein is absolutely correct in the rest of his observations.
People of God? That means the rest of the world are not people of God? May be God told them during Moses times to enter thy land after WW2? And maybe God told them thou shall steal land and thou shall kill thy neighbours children!
Posted by: zafar at February 16, 2009 8:33 AMScott: you should expect more than rockets if you take over others LANDs and HOMES by force.
Posted by: Bary at February 16, 2009 8:40 AMAt least someone has the morals to stand up and speak the truth about Isreal. I used to feel Israel was the victim just defending itself but after learing more and following the conflict through news sources outside of the US. They spew hate and racism on the blogs. They claim it is just muslims that they hate. But when you point out that there are many palistinean Christians in Gaza suffer the same as muslims...then it changes to hating arabs...which is just racist. I cant understand why the christian community largely supports israel. Perhaps it has something to do with the press as was mentioned in the above interview. After the last conflict and current settlement expansion, I now realize They are murderous thieves, perioid. They cause thier own pain by the results of their monsterous actions and cry the victim and actually expect sympathy. This is called Crying and Shooting (sorry I forgot the Hebrew name for it). Just go on any of the blogs and see the posts from israelis. The hate is unbelieveable and they go so far as to try to say that all who disagree with Isreal are antisemites and a assasination squad should be assembled to go around the world and kill all who speak out against it. The real victims in isreal are the Jews who realize thier agressive country has hijacked thier religion and ruined thier peace. I wish my country would stop providing aid to the racist hate mongers who are disrupting the region and world.
Posted by: Dman at February 16, 2009 8:41 AMJordan was carved out of Palestine by the British. The arabs already have their state.
I feel sorry for the Palestinian people. They are tool for Iran and radical Islam. The Islamic extremist types are bringing the suffering onto the average person in the Palestinian areas in order to force a "Land for Peace" settlement. Any land for peace deal is nothing more than a thinly veiled attempt to wrestle a strategic advantage in a war to usher in a new Holocaust. Israel's only real option is too allow another party to guarantee its security in any peace deal...ie EU.
Posted by: GNick at February 16, 2009 9:05 AM"Israel's only real option is too allow another party to guarantee its security in any peace deal...ie EU."
EU can not gurantee its own security lets alone that of Israel.
Taeo,
I can't see the feasability of passing the responisbility of Isreal's security off on a third party if Isreal is going to continue taking homes, land, invading neighbors...etc. I would not think you could expect peace in that situation no matter who was in charge of security. If Isreal ever expects to get along with its neighbors, they will have change thier entire adjenda and abandon expansion as well as occupation. Stop thinking they are the representatives of gods people and better than everyone else like hesbone mentioned above and show arabs, musilms, christians etc the same and equal respect that they deserve. Learn to live in peace.
Posted by: dman at February 16, 2009 9:18 AMHmm. Lets see, Hamas sends in rockets without regard to civilian concerns whatsoever AND does not, repeat - does not, repeat - does not recognize Israel's right to exist. Israel's reponse should be: a) to beg? b) give up and call it a day? c) apologize for existing? d) negotiate?? about its own existence?? e)act to preserve its own security and self interests, like any other nation in the world and without apologies for its existence - no matter the dreamland trance and hypocritical judgments of individuals who claim to be "liberals".
I say (e).
And about the rest of the world wanting peace? just listen to the jihadist talk of the mullahs, especially Hamas' sponsor in Iran.....who look forward to the day of Israel's extinction.
Word of advice: watch out "liberal" bloggers championing the cause of the rulers of Gaza (again, the ones who are working toward Israel's extinction) : appeasing the jihadist regimes and their hopes for a sharia ruled globe will force you to submit one day!! and ladies,....get your burkas to the cleaners.
Posted by: Tom at February 16, 2009 9:27 AMHello dear one:
Finkelstein, I believe, is in dire need of anti-psycotic medication.
Turning his back of his own kin/fathers, and viciously vilifying them in keeping with his, apparent, deranged state of copious hate.. I believe he needs anti-psycotic "medication."
Jews have been persecuted for thousands of years by demonic
discontents--especially murderous fanatical Muslim tribes goaded on by Muhammad himself history attests these facts, and their "religion of peace" and survived. More power to this noble--intellectual/devout race. The Satya Yuga of Enlightenment is coming and these disturbed lunatics are on their way out. All hate must go. The Jewish ideal of peace and divine love is eventually coming. "HinJews" they are since they emigrated out of India thousands years ago when their calender began after the Mahabharata war. About 12 tribes headed North and perished at the hands of barbarian tribes. The other 10 tribes headed toward Russia and Middle East and thats where we find them today. God bless them and everyone everywhere.
The universe was created by divine love, and love keeps it going.
Let it remain that way for EVERYONE!
Om shanti shanti shanti Aum.
--Swami Premanandaji Maharaja
Killing muslims makes the world a better place. I intend to improve the world. What about you?
Posted by: ed at February 16, 2009 9:32 AMMaybe if the palestinians and other islamic groups left Israel alone. I suppose if you were attacked constantly, you would put up with it.
Posted by: Larry at February 16, 2009 9:32 AMI have one simple question for all those who support what Israel has done in past and is doing to their neighbors? Will you let a JEWISH STATE like Israel exist as one of your neighboring state, after seeing what they have done to all the innocent people around them? I just wonder in a hypothetical situation if all the JEWS from Israel has to leave and settle somewhere else, which of the country on planet earth will give them VISA and let a group of such INHUMANE killing machine to exist.....!!!!!! I have seen many world leaders with a slight "GENOCIDE" tag has been refused entry to many "CIVILIZED WESTERN COUNTRIES" in past. It will be really amzing to see if a country can be classified as "GENOCIDE" causing country.
Posted by: raja21 at February 16, 2009 9:36 AMI could care less what the previous posters think or Finkelstein either.
Those of you who support the zionists are very sick. I would feel sorry for you but your ignorance is beyond comprehension.
Educate yourselves before you open your lips or in this case using a keyboard.
Whatever happened to brotherhood and sisterhood?
So long as hatreds fueled by selfish motivations and intentions continue to control minds and hearts in the Middle East, peace shall be just an illusion.
I am afraid to say that this generation does not know peace.
rattle any caged animals cage and it will bite the keeper what in gods name do the Israelis think, they can steal all the land put thousands of people in concentration camps and they will lick their feet...to bad we liberated them, maybe 60 plus years in a concentration camp would have been more useful in liberating their minds i quess that is a Jew's thinking on the gaza strip...after the genocide in gaza the jews now look worse than the Nazis in the would opinion..they have replaced hitler as being the new war mongers and murders
Posted by: gail stangeland at February 16, 2009 9:48 AMFinkelstein is neither credible nor creditable. I live in Israel and actually see what goes in here, day in and day out. When Finkelstein can say things like: "They send a Sherman tank to a playground and torch children . . ." you really have to wonder what planet he is living on. Israeli soldiers do no such thing.
On the other side of the ledger, though, we have countless instances were Palestinian "freedom fighters" have blown themselves up - and sent their children to incinerate themselves in Israeli Pizzerias, commuter busses, discos, hotels, etc.
One has merely to read the Hamas charter, or watch "moderate" Palestinian Authority TV, scan the videos of Pro-Hamas rallies in Britain, etc. to get an idea of who is actually fomenting hate and violence in this region.
Finkelstein wouldn't know a moral argument if it bit him on the lip. Sure, Israel is not perfect. But we have a lot of internal criticism -and we try. The IDF is eons ahead of any other (actually fighting) army you can name in terms of the moral restraint with which it deploys force. If Israel wished to raze Gaza, it could have done so in less than a day.
And enough with the nonsense about 'stolen land' and "occupation" as the justification for Palestinian/Arab hostility toward the Jews. The Grand Mufti of Jerusalem joined forces with Hitler to murder Jews long before the State of Israel existed. The land we captured from Jordan and Egypt - not any entity called Palestine - was illegally occupied by those countries for years. No one said "boo". Fortunately for Israel, the Arabs have simply lost every war they waged to try and purge the land of Jews.
Ever notice that only the Arabs insist that Jews must leave the land as a precondition to peace-? We never demand that Arabs leave. Then they have the gall to accuse us of ethnic cleansing. Please. The only "ethnic cleansing" that has taken place here in the last decade is when every single Jew was transferred from Gaza to give the Palestinians a chance to show they could build a peaceful society and merit anothr Islamic republic in the region. After looting the 17M of greenhouses and infrastructure that American Jews funded for them ,the Palestininans eventually turned on each other and Hamas and Fatah dueled for control - pausing only to continue rocket fire at the civilians of Sderot, Ashdod and Ashkelon. (None of those are so-called "settlements," by the way.)
Read the news. Even this week, Hamas "fighters" have been kneecapping Fatah supporters by the hundreds in the streets of Gaza. Hey, if these are the folks whose word you trust and want to have living on your doorstep, fine. But you'll have to understand if we are less than sanguine - and no longer give much credence to what they -or their supporters- have to say when preaching morality.
Posted by: Elihu at February 16, 2009 10:00 AMI cannot believe everyone believes what the press published on Israel. Perhaps I can start a press release stating that Israel is going to nuke the world and send everyone to eternity. What ignorance is deplayed in some of these blogs is beyond the education, I am sure some of you have received. It is mine numbing to believe that there are that many people that hate Israel. Why don't you people request that your neighboring countries support peace by offering a portion of their country to the PLO for establishing a new country. Come on step up and consider that as a peace proposal. Get Lebanon, Syria and Egypt to support the peace process by surrendering some of their country to the cause of peace.
Posted by: Mark at February 16, 2009 10:02 AMIsralies say that they have the rights to
survive..
Y they want survive in a land that is does not belongs to them?
If US and other western counries support Israel
why US is not ready to give its part of land
to them?
US beign the 3rd largest country can be generous to do this?
Isreal has the technology and skill to protect itself...they have been restained from evaporating Iran, Eygpt, Syria, or Libya..Occupation of what? Who's land is it? Jeruselum is the Holy City for Christians, Jews, and Muslims...It should be a place of Peace amongst all denominations, yet human emotion and ignorance create violence and unrest. The Palestinians are held in concentration (borders) camps just as the Jews were in WWII...I understand both views, a peoples land taken, the other, the Right to Exist...a neverending war...Open your fist and offer a hand, you are the same family...
Posted by: The Flo at February 16, 2009 10:24 AMIsrael is and Israel will be. Death to all Muslims. Long live the State of Israel. YHVH will win the day. Repent.
Posted by: Michael Angel at February 16, 2009 10:27 AMAll my respect to Mr. Finkelstein!
I am glad that people begin to see behind the curtain.
Media is powerful and indeed is crowded with Jewish editorialists.
As a Christian I can see many times that Jews don't hate only Muslims but Christianns too! Just that they don't show it openly.
Death to all of the filthy Arab scum, once and for all. YISRAEL CHAI!
Posted by: Aravim Masrichim at February 16, 2009 10:49 AMfinkelstein is deluded. Islam is Satan's answer to the new covenant brought by our savior Jesus Christ. followers of Islam are servants of Satan. thank God His original chosen people are combatting the menace of Islam.
Posted by: Amos at February 16, 2009 10:54 AMExcuse me,but was not the 6 day war an attack on Israel by other Middle Eastern parties? We don't see Israel sending out suicide bombers after Muslims, do we? Also, the fanatic Muslims who do this not only attack them, but other countries, torture their own people to force themto fight for them, use them as human shields, kidnap peacekeepers and threaten to or actually do kill them!
In this last fight they had with them,from two different directions, I did not see the Israelis hiding in the hospitals to protect their soldiers, using children and women as protection. The ignorants here are the muslims. this is supposed to be the holy land, for both of them and if they were willing to see it that way, I am sure that they could come to an understanding and there would be no war. instead, the muslim cowards hide behind women and call themselves freedom fighters. if Finkelstein can't see that, he has his head shoved too far up his a** to see it for himself. he should look to the truth, not for money or publicity.
Here in South Africa we had a bad racist war which was just going to get worse and worse, then Nelson Mandela and FW de Klerk stepped up and said, what are we fighting for? It took a man with a HUGE heart, like Mandela, to forgive and be prepared to start from scratch. Now it's a fact that by the year 2050, Muslim will be the world's major religion. If Israel hasn't achieved an accommodation with Muslims by then, it's goodbye Israel. Like I feel very sorry for those guys because of the Holocaust and all the centuries of pogroms, but Israel, this time you've got nobody else to blame.
Posted by: Mike at February 16, 2009 11:09 AMIn my humble opinion, As long as Fear, Envy, Strife, jealousy, greed and Hatred exist and, it will, because lets be honest some of this treat exist in all, The good book says all have sinned. There will never be real peace, anywhere in the world as long as the real truth is rejected, in the good book I read of a question ask of one, What is truth? The response was "I am the way, The truth and the life" adding that no man can come to where I would guess man want to be, peace love harmony etc., unless or except he guide us there.
Posted by: Frank at February 16, 2009 11:11 AMThe truth has been emerging that Jews and Arabs have not, after all, been enemies for centuries. In fact, it was Constantine, the Christian emperor of Rome, who ordered all Jews out of Palestine on pain of death. When the Arabs conquered the Roman rulers of Palestine in the 600s and took control of Palestine, they invited the Jews back in, as fellow "people of the Book." Again, it was Christian knights in the Middle Ages who slaughtered thousands of Muslims and hundreds of Jews in Palestine in order to "purify" the Holy Land, and Christian Europe that carried out the Holocaust. Palestinian Jews and Arabs (both Christian and Muslim Arabs) got along as respectful neighbors of one another for many centuries, until the development of the European Zionist dream, in the late 19th and the 20th centuries, of making the Arabs leave Palestine in order to establish a "Jewish nation." In the 1940s, the Jewish National Fund and the armed and organized Jewish military commandos carried out ethnic cleansing, chasing Palestinian families from their homes, villages, and lands where many had lived for 1000 years and murdering all men, women, and children who resisting. (For those who have forgotten what "ethnic cleansing" means, the Bosnian Serbs slaughtered thousands of Bosnian Muslims and raped their women during the ethnic cleansing of the 1980s, and the Serbs of Serbia did the same to ethnically Albanian citizens of Kosovo a few years later, until NATO intervened by bombing Serbia.) During the ethnic cleansing of Palestine by armed and organized European Zionist terrorists, entire Palestine villages and towns were massacred. The "heroes" of the founding of Israel were the mass murderers who planned and executed these massive crimes against humanity. Not only did the USA and the European countries not defend the Palestinians, they "recognized" Israel as a nation and massively funded and armed Israel, out of sympathy for Jewish families that had been victims of the Holocaust in Europe and guilt for not intervening to rescue them years earlier than we finally did. Remember, no Palestinians ever built concentration camps or designed diabolical gas ovens for killing Jews. If there are Palestinians who resent or even hate "Jews" today, this is certainly not "antisemitism" (which has always meant anti-Jewish racial prejudice, such as Nazi racism), but it is a natural reaction to the brutal, violent oppression that the large scale presence of an ethnically European Zionist Jews has constituted since "the Catastrophe" (al Nakba) of ethnic cleansing in Palestine by those Europeans. Remember that the category of "Semite" includes several ancient peoples, including Arabs, Hebrews, Phoenicians, and others. As far as racial prejudice is concerned, there is no remote justification for the discrimination that daily occurs in Israel by European Jews (whose children are educated in small classes in well-funded schools) against the Palestinian Jews (whose children must go to the over-crowded and poorly funded schools designated for them). This is precisely the kind of racism for which the U.S. Southeastern states were condemned in the 1950s. The discrimination by European Jews against Palestinian Jews is indistinguishable from the discrimination of white Christians against black Christians in the Old South of the U.S.A. The American Jewish scholar, Normal Finkelstein, who is the son of two Holocaust survivors, is very highly qualified to discuss these issues. Because of the very scholarly, well-documented books that he has written, he was denied tenure at DePaul University a few years ago because of an organized campaign against him carried out by leaders of those who make their living and their reputation by calling others "anti-Semites" and "Holocaust minimizers," without any intellectual integrity whatsoever to back up their libel and slander. Dr. Finkelstein is absolutely right that Israel has carried out hideous wars in response to actions that Western European nations would have settled by means of diplomacy. For example, when an Israeli soldier was kidnapped by a Lebanese organization, Israel launched a massive aerial bombardment of southern Lebanon that left over 1,000 Lebanese dead, mostly civilians, without every attempting diplomacy, at the very time that the Lebanese cabinet had reached the decision to be open to a diplomatic settlement of the matter. The Israeli bombardment left southern Lebanon strewed with 1,000,000 explosive "bomblets" that their bombs had scattered, which can kill people who accidentally step on them. Ever since Ariel Sharon evacuated Israelis from the lands they had grabbed from Palestinians in Gaza (with the encouragement of the Israeli government), Israel has kept the people of Gaza sealed off from the rest of mankind and unable to carry out the travel and commerce that the rest of the world takes for granted as normal. Not only were they not allowed to import weapons for self defense, but their import of food supplies for their families and raw materials for their small industries was tightly regulated by Israel, enforced by the guns of the "Israeli Defense Force." As a result, a large proportion of the 1,500,000 Gazans were undernourished all of the time. The Founding Fathers of the United States of America would never have peacefully endured such despotic humiliation. It is hypocrisy for modern Americans to expect the people of Gaza (or those of the West Bank) to do so. Also, we should never forget that, in 2006, the people of Gaza elected Hamas to be their government; they are not intruders. In 2007, a small Fatah Army tried to take over but were successfully driven out by Hamas. Our own Declaration of Independence states that "...governments derive their just powers from the consent of the governed..." I.e. it is the people of Gaza who have the right to decide who will govern them - not the people of Israel of the people of the United States. For us to call Hamas and Hesbollah "terrorists" is hypocritical name calling. We ourselves deliberately slaughtered hundreds of thousands of German and Japanese civilians during WWII. We will have to talk with their leaders at some point if we hope to have any success in "bringing peace to the Middle East."
Posted by: Timothy Ray at February 16, 2009 11:34 AMIt is time for people to get educated once and for all.
Who started planting bomb and connive terrorist attacks?------> BEN GURYON with his terrorist group in the 40s-50s...the palestinians are simply giving the change to their money to the Jewish occupiers.
History does not lie.. simply open the books and learn. STOP RELYING IN THE JEWISH CONTROLLED MEDIA!
google: irgun and see for yourself.
These guys are the father of terrorism in the region..
ITs a shame that he makes no distinction between "jewish" and "zionist" There is a huge difference. I would also state clearly that Zionism, a movement begining in the late 1800's, is alive and well across the world today. Zionists seem to have wiggled they're way into the ruling political factions of a large number of countries, The US and Isreal only being a couple of them.
If the rest of the world could get past the pseudo-religious dogma that is spewn back and forth at one another, we would realize that hate rhetoric, while our enemy, is also the only real difference between those citizens of the world who want peace, and the few others who would impose they're will through war and oppression.
Posted by: jim at February 16, 2009 11:43 AMIF THERE IS TO BE PEACE IN THE MIDDLE EAST YOU HAVE TO GET RID OF THE RADICALS. IF THE ARABS DO THAT THEN THE JEWS WILL FOLLOW SUIT
Posted by: carl at February 16, 2009 11:45 AMI will always remember the Palestinian people dancing in the street and giving candy to their children the day Al Qaida bombed the twin towers. There is nothing anyone can say that will justify that behavior. We now know who the real enemies of the US are. Israel is an enemy of Palestine and the rest of the Arab world that wishes them dead. The enemy of my enemy is my friend.
Posted by: JodyG at February 16, 2009 11:52 AMPeres and Shamir did betrade their people. They brought Arafat from his Morokko grave, signed a lot of agreements that were vehemently violated by Arabs. Did Arabs ever obeyed their word?
Despite of it, other Israeli blind "one hour kaliffs" did a lot of compromises in Arabs favor for empty promice of piece. Tens of settlement destroed, thousands of people relocated... in exchange of thousands of rockets from Gaza.
Do swords to the plow was dream of Jewish people expressed in Tora, even when Israel was strong and powerful. Jesus Chrise and Carl Marks build their owns dreams of peoples happiness while Muslims sinse beginning were dreaming "to convert or to kill".
People always contempt traitors. Fact that Finkelstine is published in the country sworned to destroy motherland of his race does not need any comments.
When the son of Holocaust survivors speaks out against Israel, you have to think twice about what Israel represents. It's a testament to the willful ignorance of some people that they still support Israel's existence when so many Jews do not.
It's important to remember that there are three kinds of Jews: religious, ethnic, and nationalistic. Israel's existence serves only the latter. And nationalism is an ugly thing no matter whose it is.
Posted by: The Mighty Krum at February 16, 2009 11:56 AMIts the Jews that take it on the chin first and then the rest of civilized world is next. Just like Hitler, just like 911, etc. If you see a Government or People go after the Jews, watch out, its a warning sign that you are next on the list to be murdered, hated or ostracized.
Posted by: Howard at February 16, 2009 11:57 AMJodyG you got a point there, about the way the Arab world celebrated 9/11. You couldn't find a single Muslim to stand up and say, This was terrible, it was an atrocity.
And now the Jewish world is guilty of the same crime of omission! It's this monolithic attitude where every member of a certain group feels bound to support its actions, right or wrong, that causes all the problems in the first place!
Debate is healthy. Criticism from "within" is especially healthy. It's a sign of maturity that you can listen to opinions which differ very violently from yours, then throw out the dross but examine your own opinions in the light of this new challenge.
The following quote was from Golda Meir, former Prime Minister of Israel.
"We can forgive the Arabs for killing our children. We cannot forgive them for forcing us to kill their children. We will only have peace with the Arabs when they love their children more than they hate us." Golda Meir
You'll have your world peace at the hands of the anti-christ! It is the muslim world that is sworn to the destruction of Israel. The Jews are not strapping bombs onto their women and children and sending them into crowded marketplaces. Finkelstein is a godless jew and an academic whore with no real thought towards who he is. If he was a child of holocaust survivors then why does he feel the way he does? His own words,"Ninety percent of the population continues to cheer, to exalt and feel proud and heroic." They should. The ones that don't will be the next holocaust victims if they extend the hand of peace. Peace is a two-way street
Posted by: David at February 16, 2009 12:23 PMHoward. At last some intelligence on the issue. I agree that the response by Israel was extremely harsh. The Palistinians were totally out gunned. However, if you play with with a rattle snake, don't complain when it bites you. Hamas has to bear a great deal of responsibility for it's own destruction. To this date it still has not stopped shooting at Israel. Instead of condemning Israel there needs to be suggestions on how to handle this problem in the future. The Palistinians need to throw out Hamas or at least indicate that they do not want this behavior to continue in the future. Hamas acts like children who do not get their way or enough attention, so they misbehave and the world starts to pay attention. If Hamas continues along this line, they will die. As to deaths in war, that is the definition of war. Force Hamas to fight away from the populated areas and many less people would die. Hamas hides it's weapons among the population, believing that the world will scream when Israel attacks back. Beside political assassinations, what should the Israeli response be?
Posted by: JodyG at February 16, 2009 12:24 PMObviously there has been an organized effort on the part of anti-Israel pro-terrorist degenerates to bombard Soccerdad. They must really feel threatened by the truth to make this kind of effort. We need to balance this out. Where are all the Soccerdad regulars? BTW, finkelstein is subhuman, he represents absolute evil just like his pals hamas.
Posted by: Laura at February 16, 2009 12:41 PMI clicked on this link through yahoo political news expecting more right-wing Israeli propaganda.
Instead, I ended up agreeing with everything Norman Finkelstein said - while still humming along between more right-wing Israeli propaganda.
Mr. Finkelstein is not that far off in his assertions on Israel. Perhaps he used too many buzz worthy labels for the country, with too much emotion, but I found his tone moderate and extremely well informed.
I am with you Mr. Finkelstein.
Posted by: Liberal America at February 16, 2009 12:41 PMLiberals are destroying America.
Posted by: Laura at February 16, 2009 12:44 PMDavid I hope you get this under control and get these enemies of civilization, these pro-terrorist commenters out of here.
Posted by: Laura at February 16, 2009 12:45 PMWAR CRIMES - OPEN LETTER TO AN IDF SOLDIER
Sir
I have no proof that 420 Arab children were killed in Gaza, but I have relied on the figures quoted by the world�s media. Whether they are authentic or not, I just don�t know.
If the figure was not 420, maybe it was 320, or 220, or just 120. Perhaps even only twenty. And, I have no evidence of how old these children were. Some were undoubtedly babies or infants � as I have seen photographs of the bodies, but others could well have been eight, or ten � perhaps even teenagers.
What I do know and what I am very clear about is that the killing of even twenty children � whether infants or not, was a crime as they could have posed no threat to your powerful tanks, planes and helicopter gunships.
I also know that my religion � I am Jewish � expressly forbids such killings. So does international law. So does the United Nations. And so does Christianity.
The Geneva Conventions on Human Rights prohibits such unlawful behaviour and anyone alleged guilty of such a war crime must, by international law, be brought before the International Criminal Court to answer such charges.
That is the law and that is democracy and that is how our society, and your society, works. Otherwise, there is no democracy, no justice and no law and we could all just kill those we wanted out of the way or who were just inconvenient.
If there were war crimes committed in Gaza, by either side, then those responsible, must be brought to justice. Can you help?
Posted by: Rachel at February 16, 2009 12:54 PMI don't recall learning in my college studies that liberals were destroying America. I also don't believe being pro-peace in the Middle East means being enemies of civilization or pro-terrorist (lol).
I'm not going to spend time arguing with your ad hominem. They made me laugh though.
Peace! (in the Middle East!)
Posted by: Liberal America at February 16, 2009 12:56 PMWhat a bunk of fricken crap!!The liberals are destroying America!!That's the most simplistic argument ever...Go back and listen to your buddy FAT RUSH!!
Posted by: Johnny Montez at February 16, 2009 12:58 PMConverted Khazars have nothing to do with Palestine. This deception is hidden and ignored.
I may have overlooked it, but I noticed that no one bothered to mention Israel started it's DEFENSIVE campaign against Gaza only after it had been bombed relentlessly for months, its citizens being killed and wounded. Everyone overlooks the attacks against Israel, and then calls them "satanic" for defending themselves. Interesting bit of hypocrisy.
33They answered him, We be Abraham's seed, and were never in bondage to any man: how sayest thou, Ye shall be made free?
34Jesus answered them, Verily, verily, I say unto you, Whosoever committeth sin is the servant of sin.
35And the servant abideth not in the house for ever: but the Son abideth ever.
36If the Son therefore shall make you free, ye shall be free indeed.
37I know that ye are Abraham's seed; but ye seek to kill me, because my word hath no place in you.
38I speak that which I have seen with my Father: and ye do that which ye have seen with your father.
39They answered and said unto him, Abraham is our father. Jesus saith unto them, If ye were Abraham's children, ye would do the works of Abraham.
40But now ye seek to kill me, a man that hath told you the truth, which I have heard of God: this did not Abraham.
41Ye do the deeds of your father. Then said they to him, We be not born of fornication; we have one Father, even God.
42Jesus said unto them, If God were your Father, ye would love me: for I proceeded forth and came from God; neither came I of myself, but he sent me.
43Why do ye not understand my speech? even because ye cannot hear my word.
44Ye are of your father the devil, and the lusts of your father ye will do. He was a murderer from the beginning, and abode not in the truth, because there is no truth in him. When he speaketh a lie, he speaketh of his own: for he is a liar, and the father of it.
45And because I tell you the truth, ye believe me not.
Posted by: Stephen at February 16, 2009 1:06 PMYou cannot reason with a madman or people who are insanely polarized. Israel wants peace. You must ask the question, "At what cost". Countries who have taken in the muslims around the world have paid the cost. Spain is one. The U.S. will learn it's lesson when Mr. Obama loosens the reins. Israel should never give up. Britain would be marching lockstep if they had given up. Let the muslim countries support the muslims and keep them in check whether it is al quaeda, or hezzbollah or hamas. They are forcing Israel to do their dirty work because of their hatred for Israel.
Posted by: David at February 16, 2009 1:16 PMComments like the one just above this one are why I can't sympathize with Zionists.
It's bad to be anti-semitic (and I agree that it is intolerable), but it's ok to express anti-islamic and anti-arab views.
You can't lump every arab and muslim together, and they are people to. Let me repeat that: ARABS AND MUSLIMS ARE PEOPLE TOO.
Posted by: Liberal America at February 16, 2009 1:25 PMStephen, lets not forget that Abram was the father of the muslim world also. Ishmael was Abram's son. They turned to the pagan gods of Abram and Hagar. Abram had not become what we know as a jew as of yet. These muslim fanatics are the brothers of Judaism.
Posted by: David at February 16, 2009 1:25 PMIf Liberal America knew the cost of our forefathers in our country, or had lost loved ones and family members to the terrorists and fascists of the world he wouldn't see through rose colored glasses. His statement of not sympathizing with zionists, but sympathizing with jews by not being anti-semitic is an oxymoron in itself. What are you smoking and can I have some? I'll need it to get through the next four years in America. Close Gitmo and send them to live with Liberal America. Arabs and muslims are people too! I agree. They just happen to want to destroy Israel and Liberal America while their at it.
Posted by: David at February 16, 2009 1:35 PMBy the way, as someone who lives in the most densely populated muslim population in North America, and has since before 9/11, I can attest to the fact that there is no "rein[ing in]" to be done. However, if you victimize a certain demographic long enough, you are going to get burned (see: first and second intifada).
David: people like you have existed since the beginning of time. The whites who wanted to keep civil liberties from blacks in the United States, and still even before that the whites who wanted all blacks out of the United States (the "liberal" solution to slavery). The Nazis who deemed the Jews as lower life. The Turks to the Armenians.
You sir are a bigot only of a different stripe. Beyond that, there is not much difference between you and a white supremacist, or an extreme Taliban-esq Islamist, or a Russian Soviet to Ukranians.
Posted by: Liberal America at February 16, 2009 1:35 PMMaybe if the palestinians and other islamic groups left Israel alone. I suppose if you were attacked constantly, you would put up with it.
Larry
Larry,
perhaps you should let soeone frcefully occupy your house and dicate to you while increasing their numbers and squeezing you ut of your home, then you would leave them alone/ Perhaps even give it to them without resisting.
George
Posted by: Kamkhal at February 16, 2009 1:40 PMWrong again pinko. My closest friends are jews and blacks. We just happen to be conservatives. I run a non-profit that works with at-risk inner city kids, mostly from gangs. My executive director grew up in our program and is black as well as conservative. I have Afro-American family members also. I believe in the rights of all people who respect the rights of others, even liberals.
Posted by: David at February 16, 2009 1:43 PMI just have to laugh at your first two sentences, which blatantly show you have no argument because you have no idea what you are talking about.
First, all liberals are pinkos. Check. (lol)
Second, your closest friends are jews and blacks? Congratulations, you have friends of different backgrounds. You should make yourself a card that you can pull out to show to people like me, the pinkos, every time we question how you can be such a disgusting bigot without shame. That way you can "prove" to them that not all of your friends are wasps or zionists.
Posted by: Liberal America at February 16, 2009 1:46 PMShame Jews and Muslims can�t get along since they have so much in common.
Both believe in nonexisting socalled "gods" and similar manmade childishness!
The Jews and the Arabs have always been fighting since Abraham gave birth to both nations. The Bible tells us that they will say; "Peace, peace but there will be no peace." The Bible is full of hundreds of fullfilled prophecies that proves it to be accurate. Like it or not we're seeing the last days played out before our eyes. If you study your end times prophecies you will find that the whole world will be drawn in to a huge war there; probably over the scarce oil supplies God placed there. The Bible says the leaders of this attack will be Gog, and Magog and their hoards. That's modern day Russia folks. Look at their newest ally, Iran. Yes, this modern world's war between the various factions was predicted thousands of years ago as signs of the end times. I feel more than sorry for anyone who doen't realize the odds of such predictions coming true; they are too great to be coincidence. It's all in plain sight for anyone looking for the truth. Expecting peace, a different result than God's word, is to lack wisdom and ignore the facts. Isreali's and Arab's both beleive they are right and they will never stop fighting. If you expect anything else you will be disappointed. If you ignore God's warning about the end times you will be caught unaware and it will come upon you like a "thief in the night." The Bible says when we see these signs we should be looking up for our salavtion draws near.
Posted by: Fred Rawlins at February 16, 2009 1:48 PMTrue, what is true ?
All from the same source-descendents of Abram-Abraham. Son Isaac came Jacob-Israel given the LAND the small land that was promised and is. The other son Ishmael-came present day all the Arabs (even the Palestinian) with far bigger land. So who rob whose land ?
Never mind about this, the matter is in the heart. Love or Hate. God is love-long suffering, patience... that no one should perish. To those who hate, anger, ( satan ?) eager to take life, best can decimate as many as possible, nuke coming soon.
True said after death comes judgment. Other said after death comes enjoyment. Criminal hopes after death..... ????
Who ? What ? Your heart leading you to.....
Isn't Abram-Abraham thinking his children(siblings) killing each other. Who dispatch who to paradise ?
The choice is yours. Your time on earth are given to enjoy the goodness of what are and is created – the mystery Love(care and concern) that bestow on all mankind.
So you are standing before True or Liar ?
Killing is a must, Liar knows their days are numbered !
Whoever - your race, colour, speech/language, country, food, clothing, even religion….whatever side.
The matter is in the heart. Treasure precious life or destroyer of life that tell the different !
Facism has always been born from the "liberal" side
Posted by: IndependentThinker at February 16, 2009 2:03 PMMr. Liberal America, I must quit for today, but wish you would explain to the public what the U.S. did to provoke Osama Bin Laden and Al Quaeda? Other than being their great satan and the most charitable nation on earth, what have we done? Can you perhaps say something nice about the Nation of Israel and the United States. These are two countries whose populations enjoy the greatest of freedoms, like the free speech we enjoy today. I'll be home enjoying the Presidential Holiday, cleaning my assault rifles (-:
Posted by: David at February 16, 2009 2:08 PMMr. Independent Thinker, you may want to take some history lessons. If we are looking at the historical Left and Right wings of politics, facism emerges from the Right side. Socialism emerges from the Left.
And, aside from clearing that up, what's your point? There isn't one. Not a tangible point anyway.
Posted by: Liberal America at February 16, 2009 2:09 PMThe world is getting sick of the Zionist. I love the the Exodus story, how Moses married the ethiopian woman and how God cursed Moses's siblings for their racism. The Zionist and Al Queda should exercise the satanic presence within before throwing stones.
The zionist are the cause. Islamic extremism is the effect!
Posted by: Stephen at February 16, 2009 2:09 PMThe Jews are murderers,theives, and they fell out of God's favor. I'm an African-American who people have been used by these evil(Jewish) people. they murder Palestians with the blessing of America and they wonder why they are hated in this part of the world. People wonder why Hitler hated them. I'm not condoning what he did, but he knew of the sinister and evil people they are. I envision their U.S. made tanks rolling upon playgrounds and burning innocent children and no one doing anything about it. I have a real hatred for the jewish people.
Posted by: craig at February 16, 2009 2:12 PMYou are right. The Nazi-SOCIALIST Party. Who needs a history lesson? Moron.
Posted by: Independent Thinker at February 16, 2009 2:13 PMcheck the facts 1st .in 9years of rocket fire 28 israeles killed n in 3weeks of conflict they killed almost 1300 most under 15 years old who were the first terrorist in the 40s n 50s BEN GURON AND HIS TERRORIST. how can u condemmed a people for fighting against u when its like living in a house that;s yours but to go in the kitchen i we have to ask u to go outside we have to ask u to go to the bathroom we have to ask u .is the peace who broke the 6month long truce just now hamas or israel who killed 7 hamas in targetted killings that broke the truce israel c the suport of their no 1 friend over 5 billion in arms each year while americans lose their homes .israel army over 150000 strong regulars plus 125000 reservist hams 40000 in total .israel 840 f18 fighter jetswith missiles n launching pads hams 0.israel 240 tanks hams 20 armored vehicles .israel nuclear armed hams 0 .israel fully stocked chemicle n nuclear worheads hams a few rockets .israel 10 fullyarmed patroll ships hams a few speed boats .hams fights with stones n abrave ISRAELI SOLDIERS FIGHT WITH HAVEY ARNAMENTS .IS THEIR justice. in the last year over 150 children under 10 killed most shot in the heads is that a coincident who really are the terrorist wasnt it israel that blew up the towers 9/11 .so called taliban n al'queda allways claim responsibilty of their bombings to 2date have any of them claim 9/11 .didnt usamah bin laden not say that al'queda wernt responsible if he didnt wouldnt he claim it
Posted by: musa.chothia at February 16, 2009 2:15 PMJodyG,
A rattle snake has no morales- not that we know of anyway- but humans killing humans is a different thing.
I am sure that if your husband wronged some abd lashed out ad destroyed your family and traumatized you e would be thought of as barbarous with the hope that some justice would be done.
Posted by: george at February 16, 2009 2:16 PMIt doesn't suprise me that IGNORANCE is so abundant. Those of you who condemn Israel, have no idea of what you speak. You have bought into the satanic lie! The Jews are God's chosen people. Who knows what His motivations are....but who are you to question Goid's will and tactics. Do you understand that there is no 2 state solution? These people,(Palestinians) though sad, are being used as tools by Iran, Hamas, and Hezbollah. These groups are openly screaming for death to America and Israel. They want us dead, and Islam to rule the world. There is no peaceful solution. It would be desirable to reach a peaceful accord, but listen to the propaganda from that part of the world. They are telling the world that there is no solution, other than the death of all Jews and Christians. They force Islam on the powerless through violence and death. They teach that martyrdom (suicide-bombing) is a blessed thing. But, how funny is it that they preach it is wonderful for the man on the street, but none of their mouth-pieces are strapping on bombs. Heed this warning.....Hear the word of God.... Gen. 12:3 (speaking to Abraham and his decendants...) And I will bless them that bless thee, and curse him that curseth thee: and in thee shall all families of the world be blessed.
Heed the word of God, and know where your difficulty in this life comes. If you curse Israel, you will be cursed. Who is any man whom would judge the favor of the LORD? Humble thyself, as you are not God nor are you in His will if you curse His people.
Yeah, you can discount the word of God, and you can allow His favor to anger you if you choose...but don't then question why you suffer the consequences when you rebel against the will of God. For His word tells you of His calling the people back to Israel. Who are you to question to whom He shows favor? You are dust!
Praise the name of YHVH the living God! Obey Hia will!
I am Malaysian Muslim Guys. Sorry to say this war is not about either Religion or Race its purely about occupation and people are being occupied resisting its occupier with whatever means they have. Unfortunately the only means they have is sucide bombing. Believe me no human being would allow their children strapped in bombs to go an explode themselves unless they feel that they have been so humilated by their living conditions. That is what excatly what is happening in the Gaza. Unfortunately Gaza has been a punching back for Israeil politics and election. Unfortunately there so many people that are ignorant into believing that this is a religious war or destruction of Israel. First the Arabs must learn how to be smart and second Israel must remember the more they play this game that "i am only protecting my land" with uncontrolled offensive the more people of the world is going to say u are not better than the holoust that you want people to remember. Its like a small kids who continues to seek attention by being nasty and at the same seeking sympathy for the past bad deeds that has happen to you. Grow up face the real world. People of the world can no longer be fooled by the major media. Remember the rest world get to see news not only from the american media but also chinese media, arabic media, eastern media and they do have people on the ground and just not being fed by news wire from the west. Peace to everybody.
Posted by: Mus at February 16, 2009 2:23 PMNorman "Jihad" Finkelstein does not talk at all about the suffering in Israel. How about Sderot?
Only folks like Norman support people who send suicide bombers into Israeli malls,school buses and restaurantes.
The Palestinians already have three nations - Jordan, PA, and Gaza. That they have made of sewer of the latter two (PA, GAZA) is their own fault. That they have not made a sewer of the first (Jordan) is to the credit not of the Palestinians, but of the Hashemites.
you poor poor deluded jews...you want to bomb and kill and maim and for your god who promised you someone else's land...i keep waiting for the Easter bunny to give you America ...then we will show you a thing or two about weapons of mass destruction...your all sitting ducks..and thanks for trying to drag us into another war with another innocent country Iran...may your god spit on you...if you dont crucify him first..
Posted by: gail stangeland jarrell at February 16, 2009 2:29 PMregarding the comment of norman finkelstein,i'm an arab muslim,your comment his your opinion but remember each time israel try to seat with the palestinians on the same table and finilize PEACE,
the next hour you've a rocket heading to israel by both terrorist organisation hamas or plo.
take exemple of BILL CLINTON,what he didn't do for palestinians,but unfortunatly you've the satanic regime IRAN controling the issues behind the curtains,in support of the terrorists hezbollah,syria and the palestinians also indirectly alqaeda.something we should all know
2 years ago hezbollah cross the border and snatch 2 israeli soldier for what reason,to satisfy iran.
i'm a muslim and proud to be but not a fanatic.
we dont need to figth for peace we can do it with dialogue,if does'nt work then sanctions,but when firing at me i will storm ur house.this is what israel did to protect its citizens .
to Stephen,
You sound like a KKK member talking about black people...
Well spoken Dan Ahmad!!
Posted by: David at February 16, 2009 2:34 PMArabs are a bunch of filthy pig scum. They all deserve to die.
Does anyone really believe that if Mexico started launching rockets at San Diego (similar to the way the Arab pigs launch rockets from Gaza into Israel), the US would not retaliate? Come on folks - wake up and smell the coffee! Israel is defending itself, as it has since 1948, which it certainly has a right to do. When the State of Israel was created, the "Palestinians" (a false "ethnicity," if ever there was one) were given an option to take part of the land for themselves. Their reply: "We want all or nothing." Well, they got nothing. Too damn bad. They had their chance, and they lost it.
I have no sympathy for these war-mongering filthy pigs, and I hope Israel has enough sense to slaughter all of them - men, women, and children. They are blights on civilized society, and the only good Arab is a dead Arab.
YISRAEL CHAI!
Posted by: Aravim Masrichim at February 16, 2009 2:37 PMpeople or a community fights for it's very survial with all the means it has.All others can nots si
At on judgement because it is not their survival at stake,they will have different point of view if their a-- was on the fire.In order peace to prevail,it never prevailed ever,it is survival of the fitest.Mohamud,knew it so did Moses,do not judge lest thy be judge.Read history without bias of religion and you shall see the truth.
Ahhh Stephen. Another ignorant fool in need of enlightenment. Was it not two Jewish boys who were murdered alongside a black boy attempting to give blacks the freedom to vote? Fell out of God's favor? Did he tell you that personally? You are right Stephen, Ann Frank and many other children of the holocaust were sinister and deserved what they got from Hitler. Military machinery made by many different countries has killed children all over the world during times of war for centuries.Let's not hold one country to a higher moral standard than the rest of the world you uneducated ignorant hate mongor.
Posted by: IndependentThinker at February 16, 2009 2:37 PMNorman Finkelstein is a true hero. Not your typical israeli liar ,to be sure..Oh dan ahmad,you are as much arab as i am. NOTTTT
Posted by: northamerikann at February 16, 2009 2:41 PMPhosphorus and heavy weapons against rockets and rocks?
Posted by: Tom Barker at February 16, 2009 2:43 PMAravim Masrichim .
You should not be talking this way.
I do not wish death on any civilian on either side.
anytime ANYONE says anything bad about jews or israel they are attacked as anti semetic even if what they say is intirely true. read "THE INTERNATIONAL JEW" written by henry ford in 1920.
Posted by: jack h. at February 16, 2009 2:46 PMThis is a list of �major� terrorist attacks since the Oslo agreement was signed on September 13, 1993. Victims include citizens from the United States, Israel (Jews and Arabs), Romania, Thailand, Norway, the Former Soviet Union, South Africa, Ethiopia. More than 100 suicide bombings have been carried out since September 2000.
���������������������������
Date Location Casualities Responsibilty Notes
July 12, 2005 Netanya 5 killed, 70+ wounded Islamic Jihad Suicide bombing outside shopping mall.
February 25, 2005 Tel Aviv 5 killed, 50 wounded Islamic Jihad Bombing outside night club.
October 7, 2004 Taba 12 killed, 120+ wounded Bombing at Sinai holiday resorts.
August 31, 2004 Beersheba 16 killed, 100 wounded Hamas Two suicide bombings on buses.
March 14, 2004 Ashdod 10 killed, 16 wounded Hamas and Fatah Al Aqsa Martyrs� Brigades Twin suicide bombings at port
February 22, 2004 Jerusalem 8 killed, over 60 wounded Fatah Al Aqsa Martyrs� Brigades Suicide bombing on bus
January 29, 2004 Jerusalem 10 killed, 50 wounded Fatah al-Aksa Martyrs Brigade Suicide bombing on bus
October 4, 2003 Haifa 19 killed, 60 wounded Islamic Jihad Suicide bombing in restaurant owned by Jews and Arabs
September 9, 2003 Tel Aviv 8 killed, 32 wounded Hamas Suicide bombing at a hitchhiking post for soldiers
September 9, 2003 Jerusalem 7 killed, 50 wounded Hamas Suicide bombing at Cafe Hillel
August 19, 2003 Jerusalem 22 killed, 135 wounded Hamas Suicide bombing on a bus
January 5, 2003 Tel Aviv 23 killed, 108 injured Fatah al-Aksa Martyrs Brigade Two suicide bombers in an immigrant neighborhood
June 19, 2002 Jerusalem 7 killed, 50 injured Suicide bombing at a bus stop
June 18, 2002 Jerusalem 19 killed, 74 were injured Hamas Suicide bombing on a bus
June 5, 2002 Megiddo 17 killed, 38 injured Islamic Jihad Car bomb next to bus
May 27, 2002 Petah Tikvah 2 killed, 37 injured Fatah al-Aksa Martyrs Brigade Suicide bomb in shopping mall
May 22, 2002 Rishon Lezion 2 killed, 40 wounded Suicide bomb on pedestrian mall
May 19, 2002 Netanya 3 killed, 59 injured Hamas and the PFLP Suicide bomb in market
May 7, 2002 Rishon Lezion 16 killed, 55 injured Hamas Suicide bomb in pool hall
Apr 12, 2002 Jerusalem 6 killed, 104 injured Fatah al-Aksa Martyrs Brigade Suicide bomb in Mahane Yehuda market
Apr 10, 2002 Kibbutz Yagur 8 killed, 22 injured Hamas Suicide bombing on bus
March 31, 2002 Haifa 14 Killed, 40 Wounded Hamas Suicide bombing at restaurant
March 29, 2002 Jerusalem 2 killed, 28 Wounded Fatah al-Aksa Martyrs Brigade Suicide bombing at supermarket in Kiryat Yovel
March 27, 2002 Netanya 22 killed, 140 Wounded Hamas Suicide bombing at Passover seder at Park Hotel
March 21, 2002 Jerusalem 3 killed, 86 Wounded Fatah al-Aksa Martyrs Brigade Suicide bombing downtown
March 20, 2002 Afula 7 killed, 30 wounded Fatah al-Aksa Martyrs Brigade Suicide bombing on bus
March 14, 2002 Karni-Netzarim road 3 Killed, 2 Wounded Fatah al-Aksa Martyrs Brigade Remote Control Mine
March 12, 2002 near Kibbutz Matzuva 6 Killed, 7 Wounded Fatah al-Aksa Martyrs Brigade Gunmen Ambush Vehicles
March 12, 2002 Kiryat Sefer checkpoint 1 Killed, 1 Wounded Shooting Attack
March 11, 2002 Ashdod 1 Wounded Gunman Opens Fire at Bar Mitzvah
March 10, 2002 Netzarim 1 Killed Fatah al-Aksa Martyrs Brigade Shooting Attack
March 9, 2002 Jerusalem 11 Killed, 54 Wounded Hamas Suicide Bomber at Cafe
March 9, 2002 Netanya 2 Killed, 50 Wounded Fatah al-Aksa Martyrs Brigade 2 Gunmen Open Fire on a Promenade
March 7, 2002 Atzmona 5 Killed, 23 Wounded Terrorist Opens Fire and Throws Grenades
March 7, 2002 Ariel >6 Wounded Suicide Bomber in Hotel Lobby
March 5, 2002 Sderot 1 Baby Wounded Kassam Rocket
March 5, 2002 Afula 1 Killed, 10 Wounded Suicide Bomber on Bus
March 5, 2002 Tel Aviv 3 Killed, >35 Wounded Gunman Opens Fire at Restaurants
March 5, 2002 outside Bethlehem 1 Killed, 1 Wounded Gunman Ambushes Vehicle
March 2, 2002 Jerusalem 10 Killed, >50 Wounded Fatah Al-Aksa Martyrs Brigade Suicide Bomber outside Synagogue
February 27, 2002 West Bank 3 Wounded Fatah Female Suicide Bomber
February 25, 2002 Jerusalem 1 Killed, 8 Wounded Fatah Al-Aksa Martyrs Brigade Gunman Opens Fire at a Bus Stop
February 25, 2002 Gush Etzion 1 Killed, 1 Pregnant Woman Wounded Fatah Al-Aksa Martyrs Brigade Gunmen Open Fire on a Car
February 22, 2002 Efrat 1 Wounded Suicide Bomber in Supermarket
February 22, 2002 North of Jerusalem 1 Killed Fatah Drive-by Shooting
February 19, 2002 En Arik 6 Killed, 1 Wounded Fatah Al-Aksa Martyrs Brigade Gunmen Open Fire at Soldiers
February 18, 2002 Gush Katif 3 Killed, 4 Wounded Fatah Al-Aksa Martyrs Brigade Gunfire and Bombs at Cars
February 18, 2002 near Jerusalem 1 Killed, 1 Injured Fatah Al-Aksa Martyrs Brigade Car Bomb
February 16, 2002 Karnei Shomron 2 Killed, 27 Wounded Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine Suicide Bomber at Crowded Shopping Mall
February 14, 2002 Gaza 3 Killed, 4 Wounded Mine Placed Under Tank
February 10, 2002 Be�er Sheva 2 Killed, 4 Wounded Hamas Drive-by Shooting
February 8, 2002 Jerusalem 1 Killed 4 Teenagers with Knives
February 6, 2002 Moshav Hamra 2 Killed, 5 Wounded Hamas Gunmen Infiltrates Moshav
January 30, 2002 Taiba 2 Wounded Fatah Suicide Bomber
January 27, 2002 Jerusalem 1 Killed, >150 Wounded Fatah Female Suicide Bomber
January 25, 2002 Tel Aviv 24 Wounded Islamic Jihad Suicide Bomber at Crowded Pedestrian Shopping Mall
January 22, 2002 Jerusalem 2 Killed, 40 Wounded Fatah Al-Aksa Martyrs Brigade Guman Opens Fire on Crowd
January 17, 2002 Hadera 6 Killed, 35 Wounded Fatah Al-Aksa Martyrs Brigade Gunman Opens Fire at Bat Mitzvah Celebration
January 15, 2002 Beit Jala 1 Killed Fatah Al-Aksa Martyrs Brigade American Kidnapped and Murdered
January 9, 2002 Kerem Shalom 4 Killed, 2 Wounded Hamas Gunfire and Expolsives
December 12, 2001 Emmanuel 10 Killed, 30 Wounded Fatah & Hamas Bomb and Gunfire Attack on Bus
December 9, 2001 Haifa 31 Wounded Suicide Bomber
December 2, 2001 Haifa 15 Killed, 46 Wounded Hamas Suicide Bomber on Bus
December 1, 2001 Jerusalem 10 Killed, >188 Wounded Hamas 2 Suicide Bombers and a Car Bomb in a Pedestrian Mall
November 29, 2001 near Hadera 3 Killed, 9 Wounded Islamic Jihad & Fatah Suicide Bomber on Bus
November, 27, 2001 Afula 2 Killed, Dozens Wounded Islamic Jihad & Fatah Al-Aksa Martyrs Brigade 2 Gunmen Opened Fire on Crowd near the Central Bus Station
November, 27, 2001 Gush Katif 1 Killed, 3 Wounded Hamas Grenades and Gunfire
November 26, 2001 Erez Checkpoint 2 Wounded Hamas Suicide Bomber
November 24, 2001 Kfar Darom 1 Killed Hamas Morter Shell Landed on a Soccer Field
November 4, 2001 Jerusalem 2 Killed, >50 Wounded Islamic Jihad Gunman
October 28, 2001 Hadera 4 Killed, 40 Wounded Gunman
October 28, 2001 near Kibbutz Metzer 1 Killed Tanzim Drive-By Shooting
October 17, 2001 Jerusalem Israeli Tourism Minister Rehavam Ze�evi Assasinated Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine Gunmen in Hotel
October 7, 2001 Beit She�an Valley 1 Killed Suicide Bomber
October 4, 2001 Afula 3 Killed, 16 Wounded Gunman Opens Fire on Crowd
October 1, 2001 Jerusalem Several Wounded Car Bomb
September 9, 2001 Nahariya 3 Killed, 90 Wounded Hamas 1st Israeli-Arab Suicide Bomber, at Train Station
September 9, 2001 West Bank 2 Killed, 4 Wounded Gunmen
September 4, 2001 Jerusalem 20 Wounded Suicide Bomber disguised as Orthodox Jew
September 3, 2001 Jerusalem 3 Wounded Series of Car Bombs
August 12, 2001 Kiryat Motzkin 21 Wounded Islamic Jihad Suicide Bomber at Cafe
August 9, 2001 Jerusalem 15 Killed, >130 Wounded Islamic Jihad & Hamas Suicide Bomber at Pizzaria
July 16, 2001 Binyamina 2 Killed, 11 Wounded Islamic Jihad Suicide Bomber at Bus Stop
June 22, 2001 Dugit 2 Killed Hamas Suicide Bomber
June 1, 2001 Tel Aviv 21 Killed, 120 Wounded Hamas Suicide Bomber at Disco
May 30, 2001 Netanya 8 Wounded Islamic Jihad Car Bomb outside School
May 27, 2001 Jerusalem 30 Wounded Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine & Islamic Jihad 2 Car Bombs
May 25, 2001 Hadera 65 Wounded Islamic Jihad Car Bomb
May 18, 2001 Netanya 5 Killed, >100 Wounded Hamas Suicide Bomber at Mall
May 9, 2001 Tekoa 2 Killed Islamic Jihad Two 14 year-old Boys Beaten and Stoned to Death, found dismembered in a Cave
April 23, 2001 Or Yehuda 8 Wounded Islamic Jihad Car Bomb in Outdoor Market
April 22, 2001 Kfar Saba 1 Killed, 60 Wounded Hamas Suicide Bomber at Bus Stop
March 28, 2001 near Kfar Saba 2 Killed, 4 Wounded Hamas Suicide Bomber at School Bus Stop
March 27, 2001 Jerusalem 7 Wounded Islamic Jihad Car Bomb
March 27, 2001 Jerusalem 28 Wounded Hamas Suicide Bomber
March 26, 2001 Hevron 10-Month Old Infant Shalhevet Pass Killed Sniper from Abu Sneineh
March 4, 2001 Netanya 3 Killed, >65 Wounded Hamas Suicide Bomber
February 14, 2001 Azor 8 Killed, 21 Wounded Hamas Bus Driver Plows into Crowd
January 23, 2001 Tulkarem 2 Killed Hamas Gunmen Kidnap and Shoot 2 Israelis
January 1, 2001 Netanya >50 Wounded Hamas Car Bomb
December 22, 2000 Jordan Valley >3 Wounded Hamas Suicide Bomber
November 22, 2000 Hadera 2 Killed, 55 Wounded Islamic Jihad Car Bomb next to Bus
November 20, 2000 Kfar Darom 2 Killed, 9 Wounded School Bus Bombed
November 2, 2000 Jerusalem 2 Killed, 10 Wounded Islamic Jihad Car Bomb in outdoor Market
October 26, 2000 Gaza 1 Wounded Islamic Jihad Youth Suicide Bomber on Bike
November 7, 1999 Netanya 27 Wounded Hamas 3 Pipe Bombs
August 10, 1999 Nahshon Junction 6 Wounded Hamas Car Plows into Crowd (Twice)
November 6, 1998 Jerusalem 2 Killed, 20 Wounded Islamic Jihad 2 Suicide Bombers
October 29, 1998 Gush Katif 1 Killed, 8 Wounded Hamas Suicide Bomber Attacks School Bus
October 19, 1998 Be�er Sheva 59 Wounded Hamas Grenades Thrown at Central Bus Station
October 11, 1998 Hevron 18 Wounded Hamas 2 Grenades Injure Palestinians and Israelis
August 27, 1998 Tel-Aviv 14 Wounded Hamas Bomb In Dumpster
August 20, 1998 Tel Rumeiyda Rabbi Killed Hamas Fire Bomb & Stabbing
September 4, 1997 Jerusalem 4 Killed, 181 Wounded Hamas 3 Suicide Bombers at Pedestrian Mall
July 30, 1997 Jerusalem 15 Killed, 178 Wounded Hamas 2 Suicide Bombers at Outdoor Market
March 21, 1997 Tel-Aviv 3 Killed, 48 Wounded Hamas Bomb at Restaurant
March 4, 1996 Tel Aviv 20 Killed, 75 Wounded Islamic Jihad Suicide Bomber at Mall
March 3, 1996 Jerusalem 19 Killed, 6 Wounded Hamas Suicide Bomber on Bus
February 25, 1996 Ashkelon 2 Killed Hamas Suicide Bomber at Bus Stop
February 25, 1996 Jerusalem 26 Killed, 80 Wounded Hamas 2 Suicide Bombers on Bus
July 24, 1995 Ramat Gan 6 Killed, 31 Wounded Hamas Suicide Bomber on Bus
June 25, 1995 Neve Dekalim 3 Wounded Islamic Jihad Explosives-ladden Cart
April 9, 1995 Gaza 8 Killed, 50 Wounded Hamas & Islamic Jihad 2 Suicide Bombers
January 22, 1995 Beit Lid Junction 21 Killed, 69 Wounded Islamic Jihad 2 Suicide Bombers at Bus Stop
December 25, 1994 Jerusalem 13 Wounded Hamas Suicide Bomber at Bus Stop
November 11, 1994 Netzarim Junction 3 Killed, 6 Wounded Islamic Jihad Suicide Bomber on Bike
October 19, 1994 Tel Aviv 22 Killed, 56 Wounded Hamas Suicide Bomber on Bus
October 9, 1994 Jerusalem 2 Killed, 14 Wounded Hamas 2 Gunmen Open Fire
April 13, 1994 Hadera 5 Killed Hamas Suicide Bomber
April 6, 1994 Afula 8 Killed Hamas Car Bomb next to Bus
Liberal America, thanks for your comments, quite refreshing. and timothy ray's comments, although long, very informative; at least for those who arent living with tunnel vision. I think it's about time America and Isreal part ways. We have our own problems to deal with.
and for the record, for those who say that Isreal was "retaliating" when bombing gaza, and that's why it should be ok; then i guess the palestinians who were throwing bombs into isreal in the first place (which they shouldnt be) were also "retaliating" for what's happened to them. so i guess it should be ok for them too?......hmmm...so how far in history do we have to look to see "who started it all...."
i mean it's a futile fight since each side is merely waiting for "prophecy" to come true. Christians and Muslims are waiting for Christ and jews are waiting for the anti-christ. so what, shall we merely "wait and see?".....
any student of comparative religion can tell you that no major religion (not islam, christianity, or judaism, etc) believes in harming innocent people. so, if we all just got back to the basics of our respective religions, maybe the world wouldnt be in such a hellish state.
injustice, embezzelment, rape....these are not the "opposite" of God's Nature, they are the "absence" of God's Remembrance.
Posted by: tike77 at February 16, 2009 2:48 PMSorry James, but since the filthy Arabs do not seem to wish to take serious steps towards peace, the only alternative is to destroy them, to ensure Israel's future.
If a gorilla escapes from a cage at the zoo and starts attacking people, the zookeepers (or security personnel) will shoot it. It hasn't consciously done anything wrong, mind you - it's simply acting like what it is - an animal. Wild animals attack people, and the way humans respond (as they should) is to shoot the animals, and ask any questions (if anyone really cares) after the fact.
When filthy Arabs strap dynamite to their chests and blow up innocent civilians, they are acting like animals. When filthy Arabs launch rockets at innocent civilians' homes, they are acting like animals. As such, they should be shot like animals.
Arabs are nothing but filthy scum, and until their behavior objectively indicates otherwise, then I'm afraid that death for them is the only acceptable solution.
Posted by: Aravim Masrichim at February 16, 2009 2:49 PMFinkelstein is a bloomin idiot.
Posted by: Sigmon at February 16, 2009 2:50 PMThere is NO occupation in Gaza.
Israel left Gaza in 2005, giving Palestinians the chance to run their own lives. Despite this, more than 6300 rockets and mortars have been fired into Israel since then.
JEWS ARE NOTHING BUT FILTHY SCUM, AND UNTIL THEIR BEHAVIOR OBJECTIVELY INDICATES OTHERWISE, THEN I'M AFRAID THAT DEATH FOR THEM IS THE ONLY ACCEPTABLE SOLUTION. READ THE PROTICALS OF THE LEARNED ELDERS OF ZION. THE JEWS TRIED TO MADE THE WORLD BELIEVE IT IS A FORGERY BUT EVEN HENRY FORD SAW THRU THE JEWS AND SAID THE PROTICALS ARE TRUE.
Posted by: jack h. at February 16, 2009 2:56 PMI think soft jewish targets (synagogues, yeshivas, businesses, jewspapers)should be hit over and over again in the former america and londonistan.
I think the women and children should be especially targetted.
Posted by: cuthean at February 16, 2009 2:56 PMAfter 60 years of jewish brainwashing ENOUGH! The Zionist problem will never end because they are the problem.As the wise Dr. Norman says, these are clearly WAR CRIMES of the 1st order. Think hard my fellow Californians-do we stand for baby killing? . Boycott Israeli products.Go to boycottisraeligoods.org; start with starbucks and nestle. It's working starbucks has already closed close to 1000 stores-more to come.Most of the people on this site are clearly in denial-especially swami ji- anyone who is truly enlightened would not be in support of the war crimes at the Gaza Concentration camp.Israel has betrayed our country more times than we can count.
Posted by: rick wainwright at February 16, 2009 3:00 PMIf the Palestinians have 10% of the arms, planes, tanks, missiles etc etc - there will be no Israel in a few weeks.
Sitting on the shoulders of a Giant (USA) Israel believes that it is powerful and strong.
It is surprising - the people who cries 24 hours a day that they have been penalized for being Jews and that millions of them were killed by Christians during Inquisition and Holocaust - are causing untold miseries to unarmed people of Palestine.The zionist Jews who called themselves as the 'chosen people' (How come God will prefer some people over others is very hard to digest) If God have chosen them during the time of Prophet Moses than for sure it is right because they were the only ones who were Worshiping the One and Only God. Now the true followers of Jesus and Mohammad are also worshiping the One and Only God. So all Christians and Moslems are the Chosen ones.
How can any one - whatever religion he or she may follow can cause this much of blood shed of the innocents ?
No body is immune from the Wrath of God - these Jews of Israel will pay one day and that is coming very soon
do a google searh for "THE INTERNATIONAL JEW" written by henry ford 1920.
Posted by: jack h. at February 16, 2009 3:02 PMHey Jack, I saw you on the news the other day.
Ku Klux Klan rally in downtown.You were there!
Israel has every right to kill the filthy Arab bastards, and should continue to do so. Who gives a damn what an anti-Semite like Henry Ford (and his shitty "Fix or Repair Daily" going-out-of-business company cars) said? If the Israelis had sense, they would drop "THE BOMB" on anyone who opposed them and just be done with the whole damn thing.
Filthy Arab sand niggers are worthless and should be banished from the earth forever.
Posted by: Aravim Masrichim at February 16, 2009 3:04 PMjames you schmoe jew asshole, you jews always throw the racist card or accuse antimetic when you jews are the most racist in the world. you scum really hate people speaking the truth.
Posted by: jack h at February 16, 2009 3:07 PMWell the Genie is out of the bottle and can't be put back in. The hate and bigotry of the Isreali's and Zionists is out for the world to see...just look at the hate in the posts here. I am amazed that anyone would want this much hate associated with thier religion. If you read the news here you would only think fithly muslims spoke this way. Sad really...on all sides.
Posted by: Dman at February 16, 2009 3:08 PMGee, Dman, it's kind of hard not to hate the animals that strap dynamite to their chests and go into wedding receptions to blow people up, don't you think? If you think that the people who are blown up should be sympathetic to that type of behavior, then you are truly delusional.
Posted by: Aravim Masrichim at February 16, 2009 3:11 PMJews like Finkelstine will save Israel from self destruction. Zionists have written clearly over the last century about their dreams and goals. Their actions have spoken even louder.
Do the rest of us really want to spend our time determining if a man in a turban obsessed with facial hair who dresses his wife in a bee keeper suit is better or worse than a man adorned with ringlets, donning a cake box for a hat and who makes his wife wear a wig to cover her hair? No we don't. We want to go to work, pay taxes and get on with it. But we have chosen the latter.
Many billions of tax dollars later, we are tired of the mess created by these bellicose hate mongers. Endless, senseless killing. The result of which has created powerful extremists on the other side, putting our own security at risk. Any voice of dissent is an anti-Semite or Hitler. Any Jewish voice is first and foremost a traitor, or an effite liberal. Or, like Rabin, murdered.
Zionist, you can kill all the Palestinians, but there are still a billion Muslims left. You can mobilize American Christian fundamentalists to fight a war for you. But given real power, what would these fundamentalists eventually do to your people? All this would give another reason to pause - yet for you, it serves as glorious inspiration for more war.
Israel�s real power will come from the Jews who say no to the nutters. We just said no to Sarah Palin for president, after all. We can say nothing on your behalf (who wants to be Hitler?). Protestants said no to medieval Catholics. Christians became no weaker. Ireland became prosperous only recently, after the killing stopped. We do not want to be sucked any further into your ancient vortex of racial and religious hatred.
Be brave, moderate Jew, they don�t make it easy!
Posted by: baffin88 at February 16, 2009 3:14 PMhey avavim, how many black people strap dynamite to their chests and go to jewish weddings?
Posted by: jack h. at February 16, 2009 3:15 PMIts too bad that Aravim Masrichim doesnt realize that Jews WERE the chosen people, until they disobeyed God's Command. So much misdirected emotion...sad really
Posted by: reality at February 16, 2009 3:18 PMHey Jack, how many black people strap dynamite to their chests and go to Jewish weddings? The same as the amount of intelligence in your gnat-sized brain - NONE. Blacks are not the threats to freedom, democracy, and peace in the Middle East, and around the civilized world. Radical Muslims are. And you, the KKK member, are taking their side! LMAO! Maybe if YOU had had family members in the World Trade Center on 9/11, you might think differently about whose side you take.
Posted by: Aravim Masrichim at February 16, 2009 3:19 PMDman,
Yes, the Genie is out of the bottle. I agree.
Look at Jack's post . It is well known that Henry Ford was a bigot that admired Hitler.
Hitler hung Ford's picture on his wall; Ford is the only American mentioned in Mein Kampf
I do not agree with Aravim Masrichim . He is crazy. I bet you he is NOT an Israeli.
Posted by: James at February 16, 2009 3:19 PMhow is it every whote country is being flooded with berown scum from every toilet on earth and kikes are building a jewish only state on the back of the former america's treasury?
WE SHOULDNT WANT EVERY LAST JEW DEAD?
I DO
Posted by: cuthean at February 16, 2009 3:20 PMhey aravim, how many jews were in the wtc buildings on 911? is it true they were warned not to go to work on that day. is it true that israeli spys were arrested that day by the fbi as they saw the towers burn and fall?
Posted by: jack h. at February 16, 2009 3:22 PMWho do you agree with, then, James? Jack? Do you two go to KKK meetings together? Do you think we should just let the "Palestinians" take over Israel? Maybe fly more planes into various American buildings?
You're just as bad as Jack-Ass.
Posted by: Aravim Masrichim at February 16, 2009 3:23 PMdman, where is it said that herny ford admired hitler and had hitler's picture hung on his wall?
Posted by: jack h. at February 16, 2009 3:26 PMYup, Jack, you're absolutely correct. And Martians killed JFK, TWA flight 800 was brought down by a society of Amazon women who split their time between Mercury and Venus, etc.
Get a life, you fucking conspiracy-theorist KKK wack job! 4000 Americans (and a good number of non-Americans, as well, not counting the filthy Arab terrorists, who deserved to die anyway so they could get their virgins in the afterlife LMAO) died on 9/11, and you're supporting the actions of these monsters! What a fucking tool!
Posted by: Aravim Masrichim at February 16, 2009 3:27 PMTo Racist Jack,
If you were living in Nazi Germany you too as a black man would be sent to the death camps.
Hitler killed anyone who wasn't "pure" white.
Being an African American you should also know that Henry Ford hated black.
It has been just about the last two or so weeks that I came upon Finklestien and his courageous remarks concerning the evil that the stae of Israel has been doing.
A lot of you believe that ethnicity takes precedence above morals and that is saying that if a member of your family commit an offence nothing is wrong because of the blod connections that you share.
So Finklestien shout not, acording to you, critisize, nor reproach the state of Israel-and those israelis who are responsible for what he termed "satanic" deeds.
Is something wrong only when it goes against us? And does not other people feel the same pain we would feel under the same devastating and traumatic conditions? Just remember that before we categorized into ethnic groups we are first humans, and group so amongst the other animals in existence. Does this not make us feel kindred to each other?
many of us are as ignorant of the situation between the Israelis and Palestinians- both its origin and the factoes leading up to what is now the being debated.
However, my view is that if there were honests and balanced mediations by the powers that are trusted to be fair in brokering a peace deal many of the subsequent events would perhaps not turned out as they are now.
A true referee, take into account, the strenght and weakness of both parties involved in the fracas pointng out firmly how far each can go and not go beyond in avoiding ,or rather, minimizing any violent irruptions from either side.
Now, for years, this has not been so, hence the repeated 'tit for tat', and we see the one broker that has the greatest of influence, shoring up one side with weapons that are then used against- what can be termed, relatively as primitive weapons- in a manner that is outrightly massive destruction. Distruction that does not discriminate between the populaion and fighters. Just mow down the wheat and chaff hoping that as many chaffs are among the fallen.
This ,however, will not bring peace as memories will be retained and there will never be goodwill, even after peace have been obtained.
Israel must not fooled itself into believing that the bludgeoning with the mightiest of force will give it the effects or outcome it would like to see. Taking lives and making waste of the land that people need to survive from the elements of nature will not work. We all know if the position was changed what the outcry would be: another holocaust(shoab). Yet, as with lebanon, and now the Palestinians, this look like slaughtering of an ethnic people.
Why does Israel believe that it can do whatever it likes, in whatever ways against people who does it wrong? I would be mindful if ever the Jews/Israelis with such a government and way of thinking should become the ruling ehtnic group of this planet. I gather that none ,excepting Israelis/Jews, would be alive as human beings. Just the sheer manner in how they react to something that cold be looked upon as an annoyance makes me shivered.
If one look over the years biginning with the Palestininas 'intifadah' of 2000-1 and look at death amongst both Israelis and Palestinians, one would observed that the majority of those killed are Palestinians. Even with the rockets being fired by the palestinians, deaths amongst Israelis are rather miniscule.
Yet most of those sympathysing with Israel failed to see this. If you do not believe this just google it and read for yourself.
I wonder, if the Palestinians were the "Choosen people of GOD" how would the Christians have reacted? I believe that it is this flawed belief that garner the support and sympathy for the "choosen ones of GOD" throughtout the world.
And Israel must take into account when doing thing unilaterally, that "one hand cannot clap". You just don't set the rules because you are the mightier one. And as in "Desiderata": evn the dumb too has something to say. Yes, Palestinians have their positions to consider and say as loudly as the wish, just like their the Israelis. "The squeal of the mice can at times be more piercing than the roar of the lion".
I hope that may of you Isralis apologetics will encourage the hardlines in the state of Israel to be moderate both in words and deeds.
Posted by: George at February 16, 2009 3:36 PMJack,
To Henry Ford you would be just another Nigger!
now your true colors show james, just like the racist aravim who believes anyone who speaks the truth about the jews or israel is a racist. jews are not a race but only a religion. maybe they believe they are the master race like hitler?
Posted by: jack at February 16, 2009 3:44 PMjust FYI, you cant compare a "race" to a "religion." I just dont know if all jews consider themselves "isreali" and if a practicing jew says something bad about Israel, why is he condemned as a traitor? traitor to what? Israel? what if he is an AMERICAN JEW and doesnt agree with the COUNTRY of isreal? does his status as an American even have any importance?
I wish Americans would start thinking what's good for the country itself, and not about what the lobbyist say about their perspective foreign interests
Posted by: tike77 at February 16, 2009 3:47 PMJack, I am not a racist.
All I wanted is to point out to you that bringing Henry Ford into the post, makes YOU look bad.
I was born in Ethiopia. I am a Falasha jew.
That makes me a black jew:}
Its ok not to agree with Israel or the Palestinians,but don't bring in Henry Ford.
Aravim Masrichim,
Are you better than those you are judging? Please remember that not all humans are evil and you are showing it to everyone.
You think Nazisim would have killed Black folks?
Well, a lot of Jews helped nazism. Check the 'stern gang' criminals who wanted to fight for Hitler and the present israeli president, Perez was amongst them too.
Be careful of your ignorance, Avarim.
There you are using nigger but if Jack should say unpleasant things about Jews/Israelis, I think you would shout that he is anti-semitic, whether or not you are a Jew/Israeli.
Posted by: George at February 16, 2009 4:01 PMThere's too much that has been posted since the last time I was here (class), so I'll just address the last post made by James:
I believe, sir, that you have absolutely no grasp of actual historical events. You are suffering from assumptions about events and revisionist history (as are many here).
Henry Ford, being the product of the late nineteenth century into the radioactive twentieth century, was antisemitic. This is true.
As far as hating black people? That's actually untrue. As far as his personal racist superiority, most nineteenth and early-mid twentieth century white men of power of course thought of themselves as superior. However, Henry Ford has been credited as largely creating the American black middle class. His payment of $5 a day was revolutionary and transformed not only Michigan, and much of the rust belt states, but also transformed a class that was absolutely underprivileged into having a chance at a decent living. This didn't happen unconsciously because capitalism is so great or any of that crap, but because he had made no fundamental effort to discriminate like most employers at that time.
As far as Israel. Let's look at the facts. Jewish migrants were flooding Palestine for decades before the Holocaust, and then after WWII they forcefully made the next push to establish the Jewish state. That's all fine and dandy, but revisionist history (read: mainstream history) omits the suffering of the displaced Palestinian peoples from then on. If it smells like a refugee camp, looks like a refugee camp, and the people living there were forced there with no place else to go because of a foreign (or native, but foreign in this case) power, then guess what: it's a refugee camp. And they have been living in these small, crowded camps and cities, mostly occupied for decades upon decades until only 2005 (Gaza), and their quality of life has been disregarded by not just Israel but the West as a whole.
It's like the perfect storm to radicalize a people. It's not their religion that is making them shoot rockets, but it is their religion that has kept them whole while their land, livelihood, and identity have been stripped away. If my home state was invaded by a foreign power, bent on extracting all of the area possible for its own people to settle, while I was pushed further and further into an isolated and dreadful (and shrinking) piece of land by these same people, I would fight back. Does this remind you of anything? Oh yeah, what the United States (and the European powers) did to the Native Americans from 1500 to present.
Like the Native Americans, I don't think the Palestinians are going to go quietly.
Posted by: Liberal America at February 16, 2009 4:03 PMSorry George - the truth is an absolute defense. I am not hate-mongering, unlike folks like you and Jack. I am merely pointing out Israel's right to defend itself, just as the US would defend itself if it were attacked by Mexico, Canada, or any other country. But because I advocate a strong Israeli response to the "Palestinians" who launch rockets at innocent people and strap dynamite to their chests to invade wedding receptions, I'm a racist. Your "arguments" are laughable, at best.
You might also keep in mind that Israel is the only free society in the Middle East. In fact, Arabs serve as members of the Israeli Parliament. How many Arab countries allow Jews to serve in their parliaments? For that matter, how many Arab countries even HAVE parliaments?
Time to stop defending the killers, my friend, and start standing up for those who value freedom.
Posted by: Aravim Masrichim at February 16, 2009 4:06 PMIt is not that Isreal has common intrests with america. The reason we, as americans are asked of God to Pray for his people. Isreal is the gateway of the world. and if there is no Isreal there would eventually be no world. Never believe that giving up land for peace will work because it won't They will just want more land. Stand up for Honesty. THAT IS Isreal.
Posted by: Pat at February 16, 2009 4:09 PMno problem james. but i do remember that israel defused for many years to bring your ethiopian brothers to israel. i never heard about henry ford admireing hitler but i believe you. i just cannot understand how the jewish and israeli lobbys can have so much control of our government and give unconditional support for israel even when israel is wrong. that is hipocracy.
Posted by: jack h. at February 16, 2009 4:10 PMjust to throw this out there....does anyone see the parallel between the colonization of present day america against the american indians with the "expansion" goals of isreal? maybe that's why israel expects america to support its efforts to wipe out everyone else in the "holy land"...they probably feel that america and israel are one in the same....such a shame
Posted by: historylesson at February 16, 2009 4:12 PMGeorge, "stern gang wanted to fight for Hitler"
What is your source? Can you prove that?
"Perez was among them"
what is your source? I can find no such information.
The internet is a real problem for you jackasses. It took me all of about thirty seconds to dismantle your attempt to slander Perez and the sten gang.
truthwillprevail,
I am glad that you told him to read and learn the truth about the middle east situation.
dan ahmad,
I don't believe you are a Muslim. Tell me, what has Bill Clinton gave the Palestinians? The US has never been an honest broker.
The piece of land the Palestinians have, almost 90% were being given to the Israelis. let me take your house and give you a room to live in, rule your evey move, and then call in a mediator who want you to agree to part of the room you have be given to me then let me know if that was something the mediator was giving you or taking away from you and handing to your occupier.
Posted by: George at February 16, 2009 4:14 PMGeorge, "almost 90% given to the Israelis"
you are just making up numbers?
What is your source?
Also FYI, Gaza is not occupied....Israel left Gaza in 2005 giving the Palestinians a chance to run their own place.Since than Hamas has fired thousands of rockets designed to kill civilians into southern Israel.
In 2000 Israel was willing to give Arafat 99% of the West Bank and parts of Jerusalem. Arafat turned it down and started the 2nd Intefada.
I'm surprised no one has called Finkelstein a jew-hater or an anti-semitist yet. Isn't that how ultimately anyone who criticizes Israel should be refered to? What is going on with fundi-Israelis? Are they going soft on him because of his heritage?
As for all this stuff about people of God, it seems to me that Israelis do not even regard Palestinians, even innocent Palestinians, as people, as human beings who deserve to live in peace just like themselves. That is the reason why there is such popular support for killing Palestinian children, including babies. In short, they have become what they detested.
Posted by: vicnan at February 16, 2009 4:33 PMto vicnan ,
How about Hamas? have you read their charter?
What about Hamas using women and children as human shield?
Is it ok to shoot rockets into Israeli towns?
Since Israel left Gaza over 6000 rockets landed in southern Israel.
If Hamas stops the terror and returns Shalit it would be no reason for Israeli action in Gaza.
its funny how news happens. check out this news story (posted today as we blog) for those of you who say that Israel is not "occupying" anything...you especially james. the point is not which side is right, because their actions are both wrong, but the point is from a "non-prophetic" point of view, who started it.....
http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20090216/ap_on_re_mi_ea/ml_israel_palestinians
Aravim Masrichim,
I hope you aren't disappointed, but I do not hate anyone. If you should reread both articles presented by us , you would see who is a hate monger.
James,
You may be a person who knows it all. Can you tutor me? But like you asked of me, present your sources.
I do believe that one can find historical articles on the Internet which really is no problem for you when you acquire such from same.
Look how easy it is for you to call people names. I like your colour which is not observed until you speak.
Posted by: George at February 16, 2009 5:11 PMJames:In 2000 Israel was willing to give Arafat 99% of the West Bank and parts of Jerusalem. Arafat turned it down.
james, even if that was so, giving you and your source the benefit of the doubt, why would Israel want to grab that 1% when you make a comparison of the land that both Palestinians and Jews/Isrelis respectively occupied? What major impact would it have for Israel. Mark you, Israel's land mast is far greater than the combine land masses of both Gaza and the West Bank.
Posted by: George at February 16, 2009 5:35 PMthen after WWII they forcefully made the next push to establish the Jewish state
You could say that finally there was a UN partition and the Arabs tried to use force to prevent its implementation and that the attempt to use force turned out badly for them. Whereupon they took out their anger on the Jews of Arab lands, which also ultimately turned out badly for them since those Jews ended up fleeing to Israel and doubling Israel's population.
Posted by: Yitzchak Goodman at February 16, 2009 6:24 PMwhy would Israel want to grab that 1%
So as not to have to kick a bunch of people out of their houses.
Posted by: Yitzchak Goodman at February 16, 2009 6:27 PMEver since Ariel Sharon evacuated Israelis from the lands they had grabbed from Palestinians in Gaza (with the encouragement of the Israeli government), Israel has kept the people of Gaza sealed off from the rest of mankind
Not at first. The siege, or whatever you want to call it, really started after the Hamas coup, not even after the Hamas election victory--although there were some sanctions imposed at that point. Hamas is at war with Israel. No Hamas official, as far as I know, has publicly offered peace (not Hudna) under any circumstances at all, not for turning back the clock to before 1967 or for any other concession.
Posted by: Yitzchak Goodman at February 16, 2009 6:36 PMYour ignorance of history is amazing. The palestinians did not even begin to populate the area until after Israel was reestablished. Prior to the Jews returning to their land, the current palestinians were living in lebanon, Iran and Syria. They were encouraged and many forced by the arabs to jerusalem in order to populate the area and prevent Israel from having an otherwise barren and forsaken land. It is amazing how the revisionist like to rewrite history. Those who continue to perpetuate lies and sympathize with terrorists will claim their just reward.
Posted by: Michael at February 16, 2009 6:46 PMGen 12:3
God speaking to Abraham and the decendants of the covenant (The decendants of Isaac)
"And I will will bless them that bless thee and curse him that curseth thee: and in thee all the families of the earth be blessed.
The hatred of God's chosen people and His will are the root cause for the hatred of the Jews. WHo are you to judge the favor of God? You are but dust. Hear the word of the LORD!
Posted by: Michael at February 16, 2009 6:55 PMHisory 101
Israel became a nation about 1300 BCE, two thousand years before the rise of Islam. The people of modern day Israel share the same language and culture shaped by the Jewish heritage and religion passed through generations starting with the founding father Abraham. Since the Jewish conquest in 1272 BCE, the Jews have had dominion over the land for one thousand years with a continuous presence in the land for the past 3,300 years.
After the Romans conquered Jerusalem about 2,000 years ago, Jewish people were expelled and dispersed to the Diaspora, and the Land of Israel was ruled by Rome, by Islamic and Christian crusaders, by the Ottoman Empire, and by the British Empire.
Throughout centuries Jews prayed to return from the Diaspora to Israel. During the first half of the 20th century there were major waves of immigration of Jews back to Israel from the Arab countries and from Europe. In 1948 Jews reestablished their sovereignty over their ancient homeland with the establishment of the modern State of Israel.
It was only after the Jews re-inhabited their historic homeland of Judea and Samaria, that the myth of a Palestinian nation was created and marketed worldwide. Jews come from Judea, not Palestinians. There is no language known as Palestinian, or any Palestinian culture distinct from that of all the Arabs in the area. There has never been a land known as Palestine governed by Palestinians. Palestinians are Arabs indistinguishable from Arabs throughout the Middle East. The Palestinian National Charter adopted by the PLO states this fact in the first article (See the covenant)
The area called Palestine included the territories of present day Israel and Jordan. Under Lausanne agreement of 1923 Turkey transferred all claims to Palestine to mandatory power Britain. In 1922 Britain allocated nearly 80% of Palestine to Transjordan. In 1947 UN partitioned this remaining land into two states, a second Arab state, Palestine, and Israel. The great majority of Arabs in greater Palestine and Israel share the same culture, language and religion. The Arabs in the area began identifying themselves as part of a Palestinian people in 1967, two decades after the establishment of the modern State of Israel. Virtually all the Arabs in Judea, Samaria and Gaza in the West Bank of Jordan River have complete autonomy under the rule of the Palestinian Authority.
The UN partition plan of 1947 was rejected by all the Arab countries. Arab leadership in Israel and in the countries surrounding Israel, planned a Jihad, holy war, against Israel and encouraged the Arabs to leave Israel promising their return after they purge the land of Jews. The great majority of Arabs left without ever seeing an Israeli soldier (see article and Arab sources that describe what happened during the war of 1948 that caused the Palestinian refugee problem).
During 1940's through 1950's nearly ALL the Jews had to flee from Arab countries to avoid persecution and pogroms. The number of Jewish refugees from Arab countries is estimated to be a million. This number is greater than the number of Arab refugees who left Israel in 1948, estimated as 343,000 (see Peters' book cited below).
Most of the Jewish refugees from Arab countries rapidly integrated into the modern society of Israel. This, despite the fact that Israel is a tiny country (about size of New Jersey) without any of the world's richest resources of petroleum in Arab countries. Today, the majority of the people in Israel are the descendants of Jews from Arab countries. (European Jews and their descendants constitute less than half the population of Israel).
The development of the Jewish community under British mandate led to economic growth in the region providing job opportunities for Arab workers. Consequently, the Arab population of Palestine swelled by the influx of Arab immigrants from Egypt, Syria, Lebanon, and other Arab countries until 1947 (The trend of Arab migration into Israel to find a job continues to the present day). While the British forces limited Jewish immigration, they allowed free entry of Arab migrants. The UN agency UNRWA defined a "Palestinian refugee", as any Arab who stayed in the country for two years prior to 1948. Thus, UNRWA included in their statistics migrant workers greatly swelling the ranks of so called "Palestinian refugees" (for best reference on the subject see: From Time Immemorial: The Origins of the Arab-Jewish Conflict over Palestine by Joan Peters).
Arab refugee problem was created by the seven Arab countries that attacked Israel in 1948. Arab refugees were intentionally not integrated into the Arab lands to which they fled, despite the fact total territory of Arab countries is about 700 times greater than that of Israel. Out of about 100,000,000 refugees since World War II, theirs is the only refugee group in the world that has not been absorbed into their own peoples' lands. Arab nations still maintain generations of the descendants of the refugees in so called "refugee camps" under squalid conditions with the hope that someday they will dislodge the Jews in Israel. The money spent by the Arab countries on armaments would be sufficient to build houses for all so called "refugees". Arab countries should be encouraged to care for their poor population instead of spending their richest resources in the world on armaments and development of terrorist groups such as Osama Bin Laden from Saudi Arabia.
Since 1948, after three generations the descendants of the Arab refugees are still called "refugees" and are supported by UN "refugee" funds! With the highest birth rate in Arab countries this population has now grown to about four million. In negotiations, Arab leadership requests the "right of return" of this mass of millions into the tiny land of Israel. The settlement of millions of Arabs in Israel would immediately eliminate Israel as a Jewish state. This is the real aim of the Arab countries, to achieve by supposedly "peaceful" means what they could not achieve by unceasing violence in whole scale wars and daily terrorism.
The responsibility for keeping the Arab population who are descendants of the Arab refugees, rests only on the shoulders of the Arab countries that created the problem by attacking Israel in 1948.
Quote from Ralph Galloway, a former head of the UN Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East (UNRWA), in Amman, capital of Jordan, in August 1958:
"The Arab states do not want to solve the refugee problem. They want to keep it as open sore, as an affront to the United Nations and as a weapon against Israel. Arab leaders don't give a damn whether the refugees live or die."
Source:www.science.co.il/arab-israeli-conflict.asp
Precisely! Exactly what are the "Palestinians'" Arab brethren doing for them? NOTHING! Brothers in arms, right? WRONG! It is the Arab states that have kept the "Palestinians" in poverty, fomenting discontent, NOT the Israelis.
I repeat again, for the use of those who clearly do not understand history: the "Palestinians" were given the opportunity to partition Israel prior to its becoming a state in 1948. The "Palestinians" replied that they wanted all of it, or nothing at all. The UN acceded to their wishes, and gave them nothing. In the meantime, Israel has been attacked numerous times (soundly defeating their attackers quite easily in each case), while never using Israelis as suicide bombers in "Palestinian" territory. Additionally, the Israelis turned a desert wasteland into a first-world country in far less than 60 years, whereas the "Palestinian"-controlled areas are still shitholes, despite all the money that has been flowing into these areas (corrupt officials are to blame, no doubt, not to mention a general lack of intelligence). Finally, does anyone not remember when Jordan controlled most of Jerusalem, prior to the late-1960's? The ONLY people who were permitted to enter Jerusalem were Muslims (to make pilgrimages to Al-Aqsa and Dome of the Rock). Christians of all sects were FORBIDDEN to enter Jerusalem, despite the holiness of that city for them. Jews were FORBIDDEN to enter Jerusalem, despite the holiness of that city for them. However, once Jerusalem was back under Israeli control, EVERYONE, REGARDLESS OF FAITH, is permitted to enter Jerusalem, as Israel recognizes the special nature of Jerusalem to three major world religions. Are you people REALLY advocating a return to the Muslims' exclusionary policies? Are you REALLY supporting suicide bombers and hijacking civilian aircraft to fly into skyscrapers?
All of you sickos should join the filthy Arab scum at the bottom of the Mediterranean.
Posted by: Aravim Masrichim at February 16, 2009 8:09 PMAravim Masrichim,
Please stop the name calling. You not scoring any points. You sound like an idiot!
Leftists and muslims are the scourge of humanity, the enemies of freedom and civilization and who want to destroy all that is good. Is it any wonder why they have developed such a kinship. There is no lower form of life in the universe than the muslim male.
Posted by: Laura at February 16, 2009 8:23 PMJames
Perhaps I sound like an idiot to you because you are an ignorant asshole. Maybe you should attempt to obtain some type of formal education before you make more pitiful tries at criticizing those who are far more knowledgeable about the situation at hand than you will EVER be.
The fact is that the "Palestinians" are the cause of the problems in Israel. Not the Jews. Not the Israelis. Not the Americans. Not the Martians. The "Palestinians." They have demonstrated time and again that they cannot be trusted, and that they behave like animals - not only in their warfare tactics (which still cause them to lose badly every time LMAO), but in the way they treat their own people. Come on man - who blows up UN facilities where foodstuffs are being stored for their own people? Who steals blankets and first aid supplies that were sent to treat their own suffering citizens? The "Palestinians" are animals - grow up, try to learn something, and call a spade a spade!
Posted by: Aravim Masrichim at February 16, 2009 8:27 PMPlease do not judge Israel by a guy like Aravim Masrichim .
Real Israelis have respect to fellow human beings regardless of their opinion.
In Israel, like in every democratic state,we have many opinions. The same goes with regards to people, we have nice people and we have some Jackasses like Aravim Masrichim .
James:
I'm happy to support your right to have an opinion, but you should practice what you preach and respect my right to have my own. Let's summarize:
James: "I think that all Jews, Israelis, and Americans are assholes, I support terrorist activities against innocent civilians, and all Jews and Jew-supporters should be wiped off the face of the earth immediately."
Aravim Masrichim: "I believe that Israel has a right to defend itself against unprovoked and unwarranted terrorist attacks."
Like I said - you have your opinion, I have mine. I think you are misguided (EXTREMELY so, actually), but I will support your right to believe whatever drivel you choose to believe.
Posted by: Aravim Masrichim at February 16, 2009 8:43 PMlol @ muslims and leftists being the scourge of humanity.
Blah! I'm not going to argue with people whose history lessons include biblical tales that have long become obsolete to how the modern world (read: from 1400 to present) runs. Claim Israel as the birthright to Jews. I don't care. I'm only arguing for the livelihoods of Palestinians displaced by this obvious colonization. You can paint it any color you like, it's still colonization.
Maybe one day enough Israelis will wake up and realize that the apartheid they are living in is unjust and, if there is an afterlife, they will be judged by God accordingly. 13 Israelis is still small potatoes to 1300 Palestinians, and murder is murder regardless of which side commits it.
Posted by: Liberal America at February 16, 2009 9:45 PML.A., how can you compare Hamas's firing rockets aimed at civilians to Israel act of self defence?
Please read the following article from The Wall Street Journal, page A13
"Israel's actions in Gaza are justified under international law, and Israel should be commended for its self-defense against terrorism. Article 51 of the United Nations Charter reserves to every nation the right to engage in self-defense against armed attacks. The only limitation international law places on a democracy is that its actions must satisfy the principle of proportionality.
Since Israel ended its occupation of Gaza, Hamas has fired thousands of rockets designed to kill civilians into southern Israel. The residents of Sderot -- which have borne the brunt of the attacks -- have approximately 15 seconds from launch time to run into a shelter. Although deliberately targeting civilians is a war crime, terrorists firing at Sderot are so proud of their actions that they sign their weapons.
When Barack Obama visited Sderot this summer and saw the remnants of these rockets, he reacted by saying that if his two daughters were exposed to rocket attacks in their home, he would do everything in his power to stop such attacks. He understands how the terrorists exploit the morality of democracies.
In a recent incident related to me by the former head of the Israeli air force, Israeli intelligence learned that a family's house in Gaza was being used to manufacture rockets. The Israeli military gave the residents 30 minutes to leave. Instead, the owner called Hamas, which sent mothers carrying babies to the house.
Hamas knew that Israel would never fire at a home with civilians in it. They also knew that if Israeli authorities did not learn there were civilians in the house and fired on it, Hamas would win a public relations victory by displaying the dead. Israel held its fire. The Hamas rockets that were protected by the human shields were then used against Israeli civilians.
These despicable tactics -- targeting Israeli civilians while hiding behind Palestinian civilians -- can only work against moral democracies that care deeply about minimizing civilian casualties. They never work against amoral nations such as Russia, whose military has few inhibitions against killing civilians among whom enemy combatants are hiding.
The claim that Israel has violated the principle of proportionality -- by killing more Hamas terrorists than the number of Israeli civilians killed by Hamas rockets -- is absurd. First, there is no legal equivalence between the deliberate killing of innocent civilians and the deliberate killings of Hamas combatants. Under the laws of war, any number of combatants can be killed to prevent the killing of even one innocent civilian.
Second, proportionality is not measured by the number of civilians actually killed, but rather by the risk posed. This is illustrated by what happened on Tuesday, when a Hamas rocket hit a kindergarten in Beer Sheva, though no students were there at the time. Under international law, Israel is not required to allow Hamas to play Russian roulette with its children's lives.
While Israel installs warning systems and builds shelters, Hamas refuses to do so, precisely because it wants to maximize the number of Palestinian civilians inadvertently killed by Israel's military actions. Hamas knows from experience that even a small number of innocent Palestinian civilians killed inadvertently will result in bitter condemnation of Israel by many in the international community.
Israel understands this as well. It goes to enormous lengths to reduce the number of civilian casualties -- even to the point of foregoing legitimate targets that are too close to civilians.
Until the world recognizes that Hamas is committing three war crimes -- targeting Israeli civilians, using Palestinian civilians as human shields, and seeking the destruction of a member state of the United Nations -- and that Israel is acting in self-defense and out of military necessity, the conflict will continue."
By ALAN M. DERSHOWITZ The Wall Street Journal, page A13
Hey Lib
Since when is war supposed to be proportional? Is this some new concept? Was it proportional that the Japanese killed a few thousand Americans at Pearl Harbor, and the Americans killed a few HUNDRED thousand at Hiroshima and Nagasaki? Funny how you liberals love the "proportionality" argument where Israel is concerned, but conveniently ignore it when the US does exactly the same thing!
Posted by: Aravim Masrichim at February 16, 2009 10:04 PMJames: Hamas fires rockets in a direction and they hit what they hit. That's all they can do. They use crude weapons, but they do so in an act of resistance and defiance to the exploitation of their people. Fitting since their name means Islamic Resistance Movement. Don't get me wrong, Hamas is quite guilty of crimes against humanity too - the rockets, however crude and inaccurate they are, do hit civilians more than any other human target and that is inexcusable in its own right.
Aravim: Proportion in war is a farce, but so is your logic. I'm supposed to feel sympathy for your Gaza war because politicians 60 years ago dropped experimental weapons on a force that was bent on fighting until the end?
I make no apologies or excuses for what the United States has done. I absolutely love my country, its diversity, its social structure (even though it needs work), everything. That doesn't mean I turn a blind eye to the use of nuclear weapons on a civilian population, or the exploitation of Native Americans and African Americans and the Irish and many others. The US has had some mighty growing pains, and we aren't done yet.
Posted by: Liberal America at February 16, 2009 10:16 PMHey Lib
Here's a radical proposition - if the "Palestinian politicians" can keep their population from firing rockets into another sovereign territory, thereby putting innocent civilians at risk, maybe Israel would stop retaliating! Hmmmm - genius, no? Unfortunately, impossible, since the "Palestinians" refuse to keep their promises when it comes to false professions of peace - always have, always will.
Egypt and Jordan have both signed peace treaties with Israel, and in the years since both countries' economic prosperity (as compared to the years before such treaties were signed) has grown tremendously. Coincidence? I think not. Those countries that have chosen to preach AND practice peace with Israel have benefited from this wise decision. If the "Palestinians" had a modicum of intelligence, they'd do the same.
Posted by: Aravim Masrichim at February 16, 2009 10:21 PMLA
According to your logic,Israel should nuke Gaza because Hamas is bent on fighting untill the end ???
Touche James! First good point you've raised! Maybe the world can finally confirm once and for all whether or not Israel really has "the bomb" - and what better way to find out!
Posted by: Aravim Masrichim at February 16, 2009 10:25 PMI didn't want to get sucked into this kind of a debate, where I am defending out-of-context points to people who think nationalism and political propaganda is equal to actual historical fact.
Aravim: Both Egypt and Jordon have their sovereignty. They have also waked up to smell the coffee, and the reality of Israel. It's true, Hamas for the most part has not. However, why is it so hard to understand why? Instead of trying to right the wrongs committed in the past, Israel insists on always retaliating with massive force - thereby radicalizing yet another generation of Palestinians each time. It's not necessary, and ultimately works against Israel since they just essentially create a self sustaining cycle of violence and madness. You can't pacify an entire group of human beings with just force, no matter how many times you try.
James: My logic and your understanding of my logic are two different animals.
Posted by: Liberal America at February 16, 2009 10:30 PMIf Israel did decide to nuke the Palestinians, and commit mass murder in the process by the way, they would also be in trouble themselves. For one, the nuclear fallout in the air and (more importantly) in the ground water would poison the entire region.
Let's not forget those happy peace treaties with Egypt and Jordan would probably be nullified at that point too.
Please, use your bomb and show the world your true colors.
Posted by: Liberal America at February 16, 2009 10:36 PM"Hamas murder campaign in Gaza exposed.
Islamist regime has killed dozens and tortured others as 'collaborators' with Israel in war's aftermath, Amnesty and Guardian sources say
New evidence has emerged revealing the extent of the crackdown by Hamas during and after Israel's war in Gaza last month.
Amnesty International said Hamas forces and militias were involved in a "campaign of abductions, deliberate and unlawful killings, torture and death threats against those they accuse of 'collaborating' with Israel, as well as opponents and critics". It said at least two dozen men had been shot by Hamas since the end of December and "scores of others" shot in the legs, kneecapped or beaten.Amnesty gave detailed accounts of some of the cases and said there was "incontrovertible evidence" that Hamas security forces and militia were "responsible for grave human rights abuses".
source:guardian.co.uk, Friday 13 February 2009
Posted by: James at February 16, 2009 10:38 PMLib
You miss the point. Don't forget that Israel retaliated against both Egypt and Jordan with massive force - numerous times, at that - but the difference between these sovereign states and the "Palestinian" people is that Egypt and Jordan have relatively stable governments, and they practice what they preach. They both realized that peace with Israel was not caving in, but rather ensuring their OWN success in the global society.
This is precisely the problem. If the "Palestinian" leaders (internationally recognized as terrorists, but that doesn't seem to concern you so I won't belabor that point) can come to the table, as did Egypt and Jordan, make sacrifices (yeah - real sacrifice to keep your population from firing rockets at civilians) in exchange for receiving things from the other side (e.g. international recognition, massive foreign investment, tourism dollars, perpetual peace and security, to name but a few), then there would be a peace treaty signed in no time. But, unlike Egypt and Jordan, the "Palestinians" simply do not honor their commitments. It has nothing to do with the justifiable violence the Israelis engage in against them, as stated above, because this was the case with both Egypt and Jordan. It does have to do with the will of the "Palestinian" people to end this dispute, once and for all, like human beings in a modern, global society, instead of like savages.
Posted by: Aravim Masrichim at February 16, 2009 10:40 PM"The Day of Judgement will not come about until Muslims fight the Jews (killing the Jews), when the Jew will hide behind stones and trees. The stones and trees will say O Muslims, O Abdulla, there is a Jew behind me, come and kill him. Only the Gharkad tree, would not do that because it is one of the trees of the Jews." (related by al-Bukhari and Muslim)."
Source: Hamas charter
Posted by: James at February 16, 2009 10:41 PMNo one listen to LiberalAmerica. He does not know history and only repeats what his liberal one-sided facist teacher taught him in class today. If you do not want to debate than get the fuck off this blog. Yes murder begets more murder. There is no colonization or apartheid occurring in Palestine. The Israeli-Palestinian Conflict is not analogous with South Africa. The people in South Africa were one sovereign and kept separate because of racist idealogy. The Israeli-Palestinian conflict involves one sovereign involved in a land dispute with hostile enemies that want to destroy it. It is ok for any sovereign power to keep hostile non-citizens out of its country and keep its borders secure. That is not apartheid. It is basic international law.
Posted by: IndependentThinker at February 16, 2009 10:43 PMThanks Indy!
FINALLY - someone who gets it! Time for the liberals to run off to the corner and wonder why Obama can't seem to find any Cabinet nominees who have paid their taxes...
Posted by: Aravim Masrichim at February 16, 2009 10:46 PMIndependentThinker,
Very well said.
Why have a discussion if you're only going to tell people not to listen to opposing arguments?
Because you don't want a discussion.
And Independent Thinker, I stopped responding to you because you're clearly an idiot. Your argument that facism emerges from the Left because Nazi stood for "National Socialists" was not even worth my time.
Posted by: Liberal America at February 16, 2009 10:49 PMHey guys, Independent Thinker,Liberal America ,
stay cool, do not become like the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
Can we all get along.........
If it's any consolation James, I have enjoyed our arguments. You are far more moderate than some others here, and I respect that.
Doesn't change my stance on anything discussed thus far though.
Posted by: Liberal America at February 16, 2009 11:04 PMProbably because you know I was right LA. Hitler's political ideas would be considered "liberal" by todays standards. He had a devotion to arts, putting people to work, he was a vegetarian. He was clearly a socialist liberal mass murderer. Stalin, Kim Jong Il, Hugo Chavez. All dictators, all leftists and liberals you love and cherish.Do I need to provide you with more evidence? Facism comes from the liberal left.
Posted by: IndependentThinker at February 16, 2009 11:07 PMJames your are right sir. I should not become personal in my responses. I wish you all a good evening and let us hope for real peace among all nations.
Posted by: IndependentThinker at February 16, 2009 11:15 PMLiberal America,
Regarding Gaza, I can tell you first hand ( I was there)No one wants that piece of land.
The British had problems in Gaza during their Mandate. The Egyptians had problems controling Gaza from 1948-1967. The late Egyptian president Sadat, did not want Gaza as part of the peace deal of 1978. The Israelis had hard time with Gaza.( I was there:). The only reason the IDF keeps taking action and entering Gaza is the secutity issue.
The problem will never go away till the Palestinians stop educating their kids to hate Israel.
Gaza is the only place in the world that Mickey Mouse wears an explosive belt and talks about suicide bombing and 72 virgins.
By the way, I still don't know what female sucide bombers get?
The only solution I see is a two state solution.
But I do not see it happening until you solve the Iranian problem.
Good night folks. It has been a pleasure.
Posted by: James at February 16, 2009 11:31 PMThe truth cannot change. You cannot claim land with titledeed of Prophet Moses times!
Posted by: zafar at February 17, 2009 10:13 AMTruth is short simple and straight. Falsehood is lengthy, confusing and twisted
Posted by: zafar at February 17, 2009 10:23 AMzafar,
FYI, The real Palestinians are Jews in Israel.
read my comments above..."The Palestinians already have three nations - Jordan, PA, and Gaza. That they have made of sewer of the latter two (PA, GAZA) is their own fault. That they have not made a sewer of the first (Jordan) is to the credit not of the Palestinians, but of the Hashemites."
We would have had peace long time ago. The problem is there no real partner on the Palestinan side.
James,
If you have two homes that does not give me a right to take one.
james and yitzchah...both morons the jews also have many homes they are not welcomed in any and it is because they have your stinkin attitudes...the one were better than everyone else..if your so high and mighty how come you get more aid from the good ole use than any other nation..you would be living in hovals if not for are aide and youd be digging tunnels for a living instead of holding a bunch of worry beads and saying prayers..allday long..with your sissy hands..go do an honest days work and get off welfare from us you bigots..
Posted by: gail at February 18, 2009 10:41 AMto Jihad Gail,
You still don't get it. Do you?
Soon you will get your 72 virgins.
to Zafar,
You do have a home,in Gaza or the West Bank.
I read the above with amazement. Looks like you don't need to be a good 'ol boy to be a redneck. Plenty of them on both sides of the Arab/Israeli fence. But keep on hating and killing each other. You're doing your bit to slow the population explosion.
Posted by: Mike at February 19, 2009 5:57 AMfirst, the UN didn't have the authority to partition any country let alone palestine, and the arabs had every right to reject it. the zionist leaders were delighted when they rejected it so jews could take over the rest of palestine. then the jews launch operation 'dalet' which was designed to ethnic cleanse the arabs out of the future jewish state. they then ignored the UN[resoution 194] which called for the palestinians to be allowed home and even murdered the UN representitive, count bernadotte, because he even considered a fair settlement.since then the zionist policy has been to drive the arabs out, the ones that remained, and take over as much arab land as possible.no other country has defied the UN more than israel.no other country has bombed the UN than israel. the problem with the israelis is that they believe their own propoganda. israel is the superpower of the region under no threat from any arab country yet they always say that israel is fighting for its existance. the israeli goliath against the palestinian david whose policies are 'right is might' against the israeli 'might is right'.
finklesteins assessment is correct and its unfair to labell him as anti semetic, but then again its the zionist only argument-'argumentum ad hominem'.
now israel complains about a type of warfare that the jews invented. if israel was build by terrorism some arab think it can be destroyed by terrorism.
here a source about the stern gang supprt for nazi germany which took about 15 seconds to find
http://canadiancoalition.com/forum/messages/30449.shtml
James
You should workhard for your progress. And should not steal and kill to bring progress. It will never work out. It will haunt you. That is the law of God. If you believe in him and in his Justice.
Posted by: zafar at February 23, 2009 2:02 AMhey michael. didn't know god needed hellfire missiles, tanks, bullets,etc to do gods work.
islam and christians are a extension of judism. so in realality they are are practicing different forms of judism. they are all gods choosen ones.