If you haven't read Best Star Trek Movies (in order) at Colossus of Rhodey; you must.
I'd guess that most Star Trek fans would choose the Wrath of Khan #1 and the Final Frontier #10. (My feeling on seeing the trailer for the Final Frontier - wow those 3 jokes were great, unless there's nothing else good about the movie, it'll be great. Well there was nothing else good about the movie and one of those jokes didn't work. Scotty does know the ship like the back of his hand he'd never turn around and walk into a bulkhead. Cheap laugh at the expense of characterization.)
And I agree that the Motion Picture was probably not as bad as first advertised. Sure too much time enjoying the special effects, but the plot was similar to the Changeling. So it wasn't original but it wasn't bad. If it had been shortened it probably would have been great, but then it wouldn't have been a movie. Did you notice how Decker became Riker and the empathic Deltan became a Betazoid?
I'd rank Nemesis lower and Search for Spock higher.
The "nuclear wessels" line in the Voyage Home was funny, but now having a Russian seeking military secrets isn't nearly as comical as it was then. "Dated" is the word.
If you haven't read The definitive 200 at Fire Ant Gazette; you must.
And while you're at it read the Definitive 200 additional thoughts too.
I don't understand some of the selections, but the biggest omission I saw was the lack of any Eric Clapton albums (either alone or in a group.) And while I can understand why it doesn't include greatest hits albums, what are soundtracks doing there? And if there are soundtracks, why not Saturday Night Fever? I'm no fan of disco, but how can you leave that one out? Maybe instead of one the Dixie Chicks albums?
If you haven't read the 50 most important people on the Web at Kevin Dayhoff ; you must.
I can't really comment on the industry folks and while I like Powerline, I just don't see that Powerline is more important than Instapundit. Instapundit is a lot more generous with links. (Even if I haven't rated one in a half year. Hint, Hint.) I also bet that a lot more bloggers started out wanting to be Instapundit than Powerline.
If you haven't read the Loneliest Number at Futility Closet; you must.
I know it's sort of morbid, but isn't it a little interesting?
I never actually saw ST-Nemesis but I would rank the other nine movies as follows, best to worst:
1. Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan
2. Star Trek III: The Search for Spock
3. Star Trek: Generations
4. Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home
5. Star Trek: The Motion Picture
6. Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country
7. Star Trek: First Contact
8. Star Trek: Insurrection
9. Star Trek V: The Final Frontier
Whooooa Elie! Trek VI at #6?? I really think this is actually close to nabbing the TOP spot (II, First Contact, and VI are all inches from each other). It's certainly better than III!!
But hey, we all have our own tastes! :-)
Thanks for the link, SD!!
Posted by: Hube at March 8, 2007 7:47 PM1. Star Trek IV The Voyage Home
2. Star Trek II The Wrath of Khan
3. Star Trek III The Search For Spock
4. The Motion Picture
5. Generations
6. Star Trek VI The Undiscovered Country
10. Star Trek 5 The Final Frontier.
I don't recall the other three well enough to rank them. At best, they were unmemorable. I never liked The Next Generation Cast as well as the original.
Posted by: Gail at March 8, 2007 9:53 PMHube: I know I'm in the minority in not having liked ST-VI all that much. Though it had some nice action scenes, I thought a lot of the characterizations were off, perhaps not as badly as in ST-V, but still very much so. It kind of felt like most of the actors had either lost the feel for their characters, or were simply tired and bored with playing them.
And the movie also lost a lot of points in my book for the Spock mind-rape scene.
Posted by: Elie at March 9, 2007 8:52 AM