Wow. Maybe American Jews are starting to get it:
Nearly 78 percent of Jewish respondents in a new poll commissioned by the American Jewish Committee (AJC) agreed with the statement, "The goal of the Arabs is not the return of occupied territories but rather the destruction of Israel."
Then again, maybe not:
However, 56% said they favor the establishment of a Palestinian state, while 36% said they supported a compromise in Jerusalem in the framework of a permanent peace agreement with the Palestinians.
I guess it's the latter bit of information that has Daniel Pipes pessimistic.
But don't worry. Jackson Diehl tells us:
Most intriguing of all has been the shift by Islamic movements during 2005 from terrorism to democratic participation. Despite some lapses, both Hamas and Lebanon's Hezbollah have mostly refrained from violence this year while focusing on elections. While neither has disarmed, both are under pressure from public opinion in their own countries to do so. Egypt's Muslim Brotherhood, which swore off violence decades ago, has embraced the agenda of parliamentary democracy and free press put forward by the secular opposition coalition that appeared in Cairo this year. The most commonly cited obstacle to Arab democratization -- Islamic fundamentalism -- looks far less formidable than it did a year ago.
So this must be a good sign: Hamas and the Muslim Brotherhood are now working together. Meryl Yourish doesn't think so:
They’re just another political group. Bringing them into the process will get them to lay down their arms and stop murdering Jews. Just wait.As for me, I’m going to continue to call them murderers who will never make peace with Israel.
Technorati Tags: Israel, hamas.
Crossposted on Israpundit and Soccer Dad.
I can see the two poll results as being quite consistent. The majority of respondents feel there is no possibility for peace, but also that it's too dangerous (physically and demographically) to continue to be so intertwined with the Palestinians. So they think a Pal state may be the solution. It would just be one more country that is at war with Israel from the outside, like Syria, Iran, etc.
I can see the theory, but in practice the dangers of a hostile state West of the Jordan appear much greater than from the existing hostile states.
Posted by: Elie at December 21, 2005 11:26 AMI knew your opening line was too good to be true...
Posted by: mcaryeh at December 22, 2005 4:24 AM